Table 1.
Characteristics of observational studies evaluating animal products and endometrial cancer risk
Reference | Country | Cases/controls or cohort size | Age | Dietary assessment | Time frame† | Hysterectomies Excluded | Animal foods evaluated |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
COHORT STUDIES | |||||||
Ursin et al., 1990[41] | Norway | 11/15,914 | <75 | Questionnaire | Current intake | ? | Milk |
Knekt et al., 1997[32] | Finland | 21/9,990 | 15–99 | Dietary history | 1 year | ? | Fried meat |
Zheng et al., 1995[29] | United States | 216/23,070 | 55–69 | FFQ (127 items) | Current intake | Yes | Animal foods, total meat, red meat, poultry, seafood, processed meat/fish, dairy products, eggs. |
CASE-CONTROL STUDIES: Population-based | |||||||
Shu et al., 1993 [9] | China | 268/268 | 18–74 | FFQ (63 items) | 10 years | Yes | Meat, read meat, poultry, fresh fish, other seafood, eggs. |
Potischman et al., 1993 [33] | United States | 399/296 | 20–74 | FFQ (Block, 60 items) | “past few years” | Yes | All meats, red meats, dairy foods. |
Goodman et al., 1997 [34] | United States | 332/511 | 18–84 | Dietary history(250 items) | 1 year | Yes | All meat, beef, pork, poultry, fish, processed meat, red meat, dairy products, butter, milk, cheese, eggs. |
Jain et al., 2000[39] | Canada | 552/562 | 30–79 | Dietary history (n Items ?) | 1 year | Yes | Read meat, fish, chicken, milk, cheese. |
McCann et al., 2000 [35] | United States | 232/639 | 40–85 | FFQ (172 items) | 2 years | Yes | Red meat, poultry, fish/seafood, processed meats, total meat, dairy |
Littman et al., 2001[36] | United States | 679/944 | 45–74 | FFQ (modified Block, 98 items) | 5 years | Yes | Dairy products, meat. |
Terry et al., 2002[20] ‡ | Sweden | 709/2887 | 50–74 | FFQ (32 Items plus fish questions) | 1 year | Yes | Dairy products, meat. |
Terry et al., 2002[21] ‡ | Sweden | 698/2720 | 50–74 | FFQ (32 Items plus fish questions) | 1 year | Yes | Fatty fish, lean fish, total fish. |
Xu et al., 2006 [37] | China | 1204/1212 | 30–69 | FFQ (76 foods) | 5 years | Yes | Total meat, red meat, organ meat, poultry, total fish, marine fish, fresh water fish, shrimp and crab, eel, shellfish, eggs, milk. |
CASE-CONTROL STUDIES: Hospital-based | |||||||
Tzonou et al, 1996[30] | Greece | 145/298 | FFQ (115 items) | 1 year | ? | “Meats, fish or eggs”, “milk or milk products”. | |
La Vecchia et al., 1988 [22] § | Italy | 434/1385 | <75 | Questionnaire(frequency of consumption per week of 14 items) | “before symptoms” | Yes | Total meat. |
Mettlin et al., 1990[42] | United States | 231/1300 | 18.97 | FFQ (n items?) | ? | No | Whole milk, 2% milk, skim milk. |
Levi et al., 1993 [7] | Italy, Switzerland | 274/572 | 30–75 | Questionnaire(Weekly frequency of intake of 50 items) | “before symptoms” | Yes | Beef, pork, poultry, fish, liver, raw ham, boiled ham, salami and sausages, canned meat, other meats, milk, cheese, eggs. |
Barbone et al., 1993 [43] | United States | 103/236 | FFQ (Willett, 116 items) | 1 year | Yes | Skim milk, sour cream, yogurt, cheese other than cream. | |
Hirose et al., 1996[40] | Japan | 145/26751 | >20 | Questionnaire (n items ?) | ? | ? | Milk, boiled or broiled fish, sashimi, egg, chicken, beef, pork. |
Fernandez et al., 1999[24] § | Italy | 750/7,990 | <75 | Questionnaire(weekly frequency of intake of 14–37 items) | 1 year | ? | Fish. |
Tavani et al., 2000[23] § | Italy | 750/7,990 | <75 | Questionnaire(weekly frequency of approximately 40 items) | 2 years | ? | Red meat. |
Petridou et al., 2002 [31] | Greece | 84/84 | FFQ (110 items) | 1 year | Yes | “Meats, fish, and eggs”, “milk and milk products” | |
Salazar-Martinez et al., 2005 [38] | Mexico | 85/629 | 18–81 | FFQ (116 items) | 1 year | Yes | Dairy products, meat. |
Abbreviations: FFQ, food frequency questionnaire; ?, unspecified
Time frame for dietary assessment.
Same case-control study in Sweden.
Same case-control study in Italy.