Table 2.
A comparison of tillage, conservation tillage (CT) and conservation agriculture (CA) for various issues.
| issues | traditional tillage (TT) | conservation tillage (CT) | conservation agriculture (CA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| practice | disturbs the soil and leaves a bare surface | reduces the soil disturbance in TT and keeps the soil covered | minimal soil disturbance and soil surface permanently covered |
| erosion | wind and soil erosion: maximum | wind and soil erosion: reduced significantly | wind and soil erosion: the least of the three |
| soil physical health | the lowest of the three | significantly improved | the best practice of the three |
| compaction | used to reduce compaction and can also induce it by destroying biological pores | reduced tillage is used to reduce compaction | compaction can be a problem but use of mulch and promotion of biological tillage helps reduce this problem |
| soil biological health | the lowest of the three owing to frequent disturbance | moderately better soil biological health | more diverse and healthy biological properties and populations |
| water infiltration | lowest after soil pores clogged | good water infiltration | best water infiltration |
| soil organic matter | oxidizes soil organic matter and causes its loss | soil organic build-up possible in the surface layers | soil organic build-up in the surface layers even better than CT |
| weeds | controls weeds and also causes more weed seeds to germinate | reduced tillage controls weeds and also exposes other weed seeds for germination | weeds are a problem especially in the early stages of adoption, but problems are reduced with time and residues can help suppress weed growth |
| soil temperature | surface soil temperature: more variable | surface soil temperature: intermediate in variability | surface soil temperature: moderated the most |
| diesel use and costs | diesel use: high | diesel use: intermediate | diesel use: much reduced |
| production costs | highest costs | intermediate costs | lowest costs |
| timeliness | operations can be delayed | intermediate timeliness of operations | timeliness of operations more optimal |
| yield | can be lower where planting delayed | yields same as TT | yields same as TT but can be higher if planting done more timely |