Skip to main content
. 2007 Jul 24;363(1491):543–555. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2007.2169

Table 2.

A comparison of tillage, conservation tillage (CT) and conservation agriculture (CA) for various issues.

issues traditional tillage (TT) conservation tillage (CT) conservation agriculture (CA)
practice disturbs the soil and leaves a bare surface reduces the soil disturbance in TT and keeps the soil covered minimal soil disturbance and soil surface permanently covered
erosion wind and soil erosion: maximum wind and soil erosion: reduced significantly wind and soil erosion: the least of the three
soil physical health the lowest of the three significantly improved the best practice of the three
compaction used to reduce compaction and can also induce it by destroying biological pores reduced tillage is used to reduce compaction compaction can be a problem but use of mulch and promotion of biological tillage helps reduce this problem
soil biological health the lowest of the three owing to frequent disturbance moderately better soil biological health more diverse and healthy biological properties and populations
water infiltration lowest after soil pores clogged good water infiltration best water infiltration
soil organic matter oxidizes soil organic matter and causes its loss soil organic build-up possible in the surface layers soil organic build-up in the surface layers even better than CT
weeds controls weeds and also causes more weed seeds to germinate reduced tillage controls weeds and also exposes other weed seeds for germination weeds are a problem especially in the early stages of adoption, but problems are reduced with time and residues can help suppress weed growth
soil temperature surface soil temperature: more variable surface soil temperature: intermediate in variability surface soil temperature: moderated the most
diesel use and costs diesel use: high diesel use: intermediate diesel use: much reduced
production costs highest costs intermediate costs lowest costs
timeliness operations can be delayed intermediate timeliness of operations timeliness of operations more optimal
yield can be lower where planting delayed yields same as TT yields same as TT but can be higher if planting done more timely