Skip to main content
. 2007 Oct;13(5):328–333. doi: 10.1136/ip.2006.012328

Table 3 Alternatives to DIY and summary of feasibility and acceptability to participants.

Alternative to DIY Feasibility in current setting Acceptability to focus‐group participants
Assistance of family and/or friends Highly feasible for most in terms of availability and cost High acceptability to most but some reluctance to ask for too much assistance, as it may be seen to threaten their independence or impinge on quality family time
Use of tradesmen recommended by word of mouth (friends, family) Highly feasible in terms of safety, reliability and cost High acceptability, most noted this as first alternative to DIY
Guidebook of services and entitlements re seniors' home maintenance Limited feasibility; may become out of date quickly due to changing entitlements and professionals involved Good acceptability as an easily accessible printed source of information
Local advertising (newspapers, letterbox flyers) Highly feasible, many existing examples Mixed acceptability; negative comments include: no guarantee of the job or the individual; time‐consuming to find several quotes and; reluctance of local advertisers to take some jobs, eg, small jobs.
Home and Community Care Programmes (HACC) (funded by state/implemented by local government) Highly feasible; HACC currently provides essential maintenance and supportive services to older Victorians living at home Highly acceptable; first port of call for many; reported sense of trust; reliability and legitimacy in HACC provided services
Community Aged Care Packages (Federally funded care package to help older people to stay at home) Highly feasible for those in declining health but not for the fitter seniors. None of the focus‐group participants was receiving an Aged Care package, and so this alternative was not discussd in detail
Advisory Services: council run (where seniors could be referred to an appropriate tradesman) Not currently feasible; councils are unable to provide an advisory service of this type as it would be costly to establish and resource intensive and difficult given current levels of funding Highly acceptable with the only concern being that councils would not guarantee the work.
Advisory Services: privately run (where seniors could be referred to a tradesman) Highly feasible; commercial advisory services currently operate in Victoria Highly acceptable; the concept was thoroughly endorsed in the focus groups, but knowledge of existing services was poor
Advisory service to recommend what repairs are required around the home Highly feasible; a State government‐sponsored scheme is in existence in Victoria, and free home inspections for older Victorians are undertaken by the Architects Association Highly acceptable, but knowledge of the current scheme was poor among focus‐group participants
Service for making complaints and advice on action Highly feasible; complaint systems are currently in existence via Building Commission and Consumer Affairs Victoria Raised as desirable in some focus groups but a simplified system would be preferable
Barter systems Feasible; there are approximately 35 barter programmes (LETSystems) running locally across Victoria Limited acceptability; discussed light‐heartedly at one or two of the focus groups, but no great enthusiasm overall; there appeared to be no knowledge of existing barter systems
Community Services (services provided by individuals under community service orders) Not currently feasible; this type of system would appear to be difficult to administer and monitor Not acceptable to most; home/personal security was vital, particularly for women living alone
Volunteer groups of older tradesmen Feasible on a small scale; such volunteer systems run well for local clubs running a service for a limited number of clients, but they are much more difficult to administer and run on a larger scale, eg, for a whole local government area Good acceptability among focus‐group participants, but there are concerns about the length of time it would take for a volunteer to become available and complete the task