Table 1.
Methods | Reliability* | Accuracy* | Magnification | Approximate radiation exposure (mrads) [26] | Approximate charges (U.S. dollars) | Radiographic deformity analysis | Incorporation of height of the foot and pelvis | Typical availability in U.S. | Weight bearing |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinical | |||||||||
Supine tape measure—“Real” (ASIS to malleolus) | + | + | None | None | Office visit | Not applicable | No | Yes | No |
Supine tape measure—“Apparent” (umblicus to malleolus) | + | + | None | None | Office visit | Not applicable | Partial | Yes | No |
Standing blocks | + + | + | None | None | Office visit | Not applicable | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Imaging | |||||||||
Teleoreontgenogram | + + + + | + + + | ~5% | 42 | $95 [26] | Yes | Yes | Varies | Yes |
Orthoroentgenogram | + + + | + + + | Minimal | 200 | $110 [26] | Minimal | No | Varies | No |
Scanogram | + + + + | + + + | Minimal | 200 | $110 [26] | No | No | Varies | No |
CR | + + + + | + + + | Varies with technique (scanogram versus teleoroengenogram) | Varies with technique, less exposure than standard radiography | $137 [38] | Varies with technique (scanogram versus teleoroengenogram) | Varies with technique | Varies | Varies with technique (scanogram versus teleoroengenogram) |
MDR | + + + | + + + + | None | 2 | $75 [26] | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Ultrasound | + + + | + + | None | None | Not reported | No | No | No | Yes |
CT scan (digital localization image) | + + + + | + + + + | Minimal | 60 | $60 [26] | Minimal | None | Varies | No |
MRI | + + + + | + + + | Minimal | None | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | No | No |
CR = computed radiography; MDR = microdose digital radiography.
* Please see text for detailed analysis. For simplicity, the increasing number of “+” signs indicate greater degree of reliability/accuracy.