Table 4. Developmental maturity categories of Langer [21] and mineralization of first molar M1 and other permanent teeth in newborn terrestrial mammals compared to the early whale Maiacetus inuus.
Species | Mineralization of the permanent dentition at birth | Reference |
Category I. Altricial: eyes closed, naked, nidicolous or ‘nest-dwelling’ | ||
Gray short-tail opossum, Monodelphis domestica | None | [33] |
Brown bear, Ursus arctos | None | [22] |
Indian mongoose, Herpestes auropunctatus | None | [34] |
Ferret, Mustela putorious | None | [35] |
Domestic dog, Canis familiaris | Trace | [36] |
Category II. Precocial: eyes open, haired, nidicolous or ‘nest-dwelling’ | ||
Domestic pig, Sus scrofa | None | [37] |
Miniature pig, Sus scrofa | M1 cusp tips beginning to mineralize | [38] |
Collared peccary, Tayassu tajacu | M1 cusp tips formed | [39] |
Category III. Precocial: eyes open, haired, transported (largely primates) | ||
Human, Homo sapiens | M1 cusp tips beginning to mineralize | [40] |
Great apes, Pan, Gorilla, and Pongo spp. | M1 cusp tips beginning to mineralize | [40] |
Gibbon, Hylobates sp. | M1 cusp tips beginning to mineralize | [40] |
Rhesus macaque, Macaca mulaltta | M1 cusp tips formed | [41] |
Mongoose lemur, Eulemur mongoz | M1 cusp tips formed | [42] |
Coquerel's sifaka, Propithecus verreauxi | M1 crown almost complete, M2 near coalescence, M3 trace | [42] |
Tarsier, Tarsius bancanus | M1 ‘well differentiated’ (some deciduous teeth resorbed in utero) | [43] |
Category IV. Precocial: eyes open, haired, nidifugous or ‘nest-fleeing’ | ||
American tapir, Tapirus cf. T. bairdii | M1 anterior cusps connected | [44] |
Domestic sheep, Ovis aries | M1 cusps connected; crown one-quarter formed | [45] |
Maiacetus inuus 1 | M1 crown one-half formed | this study |
Fallow deer, Dama dama | M1 crown one-half formed | [46] |
Pygmy hippo, Hexaprotodon liberensis | M1? (many deciduous teeth erupted at birth; large M1 crypt) | [27] |
Giraffe, Giraffa camelopardalis | M1 crown complete (all deciduous teeth erupted at birth) | [47] |
Fur seal, Callorhinus ursinus | M1-2 crowns complete (deciduous teeth shed in utero) | [48] |
Guinea pig, Cavia porcellus | All permanent teeth erupted; roots incomplete | [23] |
Living whales are not included because none have deciduous teeth and many have few or no teeth. Because early whales evolved from artiodactyls [3], Ovis, Dama, Hexaprotodon, and Giraffa are better analogs than primates.
Presence of mineralization of the crown of M1 in the fetal skull of Maiacetus inuus indicates precocial development and the probability that newborns were open-eyed, hairy and nidifugous.