Table 2.
Study Characteristics
Study | Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria | Sample Size | Outcomes |
Soteria USA (2 cohorts): Mosher et al13; Mosher14; Mosher and Menn15; Mosher and Menn16; Mosher and Menn17; Mosher and Menn18; Mathews et al19; Mosher 20; Mosher et al21; Mosher22; Bola23 Bola and Mosher24; Bola and Mosher.25 | DSM-II criteria for schizophrenia. | Not reported | Cohort 1: 79 | 2-y follow-up: |
1. Readmission to 24 h care. | ||||
2. Number of readmissions | ||||
3. Days in readmission | ||||
Deemed in need of hospitalization | 4. Global psychopathology scale (Mosher et al30) | |||
4 of 7 Bleulerian diagnostic symptoms. | 5. Global improvement scale (Mosher et al30) | |||
Not more than 1 previous hospitalization for 30 d or less. | Cohort 2: 100 | 6. Living independently with peers. | ||
Age: 15–32 | 7. Ordinal measure of working | |||
Marital status: single | 8. Functioning subscale of the Brief Follow-up Rating (Sokis 31) | |||
Soteria Bern: Ciompi et al10; Ciompi26; Ciompi and Bernascomi27; Ciompi et al28; Ciompi et al29; | Age 17–35 | Drug or alcohol dependency | Treatment: 22 | 2-y follow-up: |
1. Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale | ||||
2. Housing situation | ||||
3. Job situation | ||||
4. Global outcome, 1, 2, and 3 combined | ||||
5. Global autonomy | ||||
DSM-III-R criteria for schizophrenia or schizophreniform psychosis. | 6. Relapse rate | |||
At least 2 of 6 symptoms over previous 4 weeks (delusion, hallucinations, though disorder, catatonia, schizophrenic disorders of affect, severely deviant social behavior) | Not compliant with treatment | Control: 22 | 7. Average medication dose |