Table 2.
Summary of Experience Studies Included in the Review
Citation | n's sz/hc/op | % Male sz/hc/op | Study Type | Stimuli/Situation | Rating: Stimuli/Feeling | Results | Sex Differences |
Berlin98 | 20 sz/20 hc/20 op | 55/35/35 | Elicit | Taste | Stimuli | sz = hc | |
*Berenbaum42 | 43 sz/20 hc/17 op | 51/50/35 | Elicit | Films, foods | Stimuli | sz = hc | Unk |
Blanchard125 | 32 sz/13 op | 49/39 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz = op | None |
*Brown59 | 6 sz/5 op | 17/0 | Naturalistic | Inpatient | Feelings | sz < op | Unk |
Burbridge85 | 49 sz/47 hc | 63/49 | Elicit | Words, pictures faces, films, sounds | Stimuli | sz = hc; sz < hc—negative arousal | Unk |
Crespo-Facorro113 | 18 sz/16 hc | 89/44 | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz = hc—unpleasant; sz < hc—pleasant | Unk |
Curtis91 | 36 sz/48 rel/56 hc | 75/40/41 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz < hc, relative—positive; sz < hc—negative | Unk |
Doop112 | 17 sz/14 hc | Unk | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz > hc pleasant | n/a |
*Earnst43 | 19 deficit sz; 22 nondeficit sz/20 hc | 100; 100/100 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz = hc pleasant; deficit sz > hc unpleasant | n/a |
Habel94 | 13 sz/13 rel | 100/100 | Elicit | Faces | Feelings | sz = rel | |
Heerey102 | 40 sz/31 hc | 65/48 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc | w > m |
Hempel104 | 28 sz/30 hc | 93/70 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc | Unk |
Hempel103 | 26 sz/21 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc | n/a |
*Henry44 | 29 sz/30 hc | 45/53 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz < hc amusement | Unk |
Herbener86 | 33 sz/28 hc | 58/46 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = hc | None |
Herbener17 | 34 sz/35 hc | 53/54 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = hc | Unk |
Holt109 | 18 sz/16sz | 100/100 | Elicit | Faces | Stimuli | sz = hc | n/a |
Horan100 | 36 sz/26 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Social int | Feelings | sz = hc | n/a |
Horan 200699 | 30 sz/31 hc | 83/68 | Elicit | Films, foods | Feelings | sz = hc pleasant; sz > hc unpleasant | Unk |
Hudry114 | 40 sz/40 hc | 50/50 | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz < hc pleasant | None |
*Kring46 | 20 sz/20 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz > hc PA happy, neutral; sz > hc NA happy neutral | n/a |
*Kring47 | 23 sz/20 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz > hc NA; sz = hc PA | n/a |
*Kring 199945 | 15 sz/15 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz = hc pleasant, activated; sz > hc unpleasant | n/a |
Lee92 | 21 sz/20 hc | 48/40 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz < hc pleasant | Unk |
Moberg115 | 30 sz/20 hc | 50/37 | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz < hc pleasant | w > m |
Myin-Germeys124 | 58 sz/65 hc | 62/67 | Naturalistic | Daily life | Feelings | sz > hc negative; sz < hc positive | Unk |
Myin-Germeys119 | 42 sz/47 rel/49 hc | 52/53/49 | Naturalistic | Daily life | Feelings | sz > hc, rel NA; sz < hc, rel PA | None |
Myin-Germeys122 | 42 sz/38 op/46 op/49 hc | 52/20/43/49 | Naturalistic | Daily stress | Feelings | sz > hc NA; <op NA; sz < hc PA; > op | Unk |
Myin-Germeys121 | 42 sz | 52 | Naturalistic | Daily stress | Feelings | w > m negative; w < m positive | |
Paradiso107 | 18 sz/17 hc | 89/41 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc negative; sz < hc positive | Unk |
Plailly116 | 12 sz/12 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz = hc unpleasant; sz < hc pleasant | n/a |
Quirk87 | 20 sz/10 op | 100/100 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = op | n/a |
Quirk93 | 30 sz/10 op | 100/100 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = op arousal; sz < op pleasant | n/a |
Reske97 | 10 sz/10 hc | 60/Unk | Elicit | Faces | Feelings | sz = hc NA; sz < hc PA | Unk |
Rockstroh105 | 12 sz/12 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc | |
Rupp111 | 33 sz/40 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Odors | Stimuli | sz = hc | |
Schlenker88 | 34 sz/24 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = hc | n/a |
Schneider95 | 40 sz/40 hc | 53/Unk | Elicit | Faces | Feelings | sz = hc PA, NA; sz < hc happy | Unk |
Schneider110 | 13 sz/13 rel/26 hc | 100/100/Unk | Elicit | Odors | Feelings | sz = hc | n/a |
Schneider101 | 13 sz/13 hc | 100/100 | Elicit | Films | Feelings | sz = hc | |
Takahashi89 | 15 sz/15 hc | 67/60 | Elicit | Pictures | Feelings | sz = hc | |
Taylor108 | 18 sz/10 hc | 61/60 | Elicit | Pictures | Stimuli | sz = hc NA; sz < hc PA | Unk |
Volz90 | 49 sz/46 hc | 47/37 | Elicit | Pictures | Feeling | sz = hc | Unk |
Note: Only first author of multiauthor study is listed under citation. An asterisk next to an author name indicates that the study was also referenced in table 1; sz = schizophrenia or schizoaffective; hc = healthy control; op = other patient group; unk = unknown; rel = relatives; int = interaction; NA = negative affect; PA = positive affect; n/a = not applicable.