Table 2. Characteristics of studies included in the literature review.
Author, year and reference no.a | Country | Survey type | Population/participants | Sampling plan | Trachoma signs reportedb | Problems with methodsc |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
West et al., 199113 | United Republic of Tanzania | PBPS | Community: children 1–7 years and mothers/caregivers | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TI, TS, TT, CO | 1 and 2 |
Sukwa et al., 199214 | Zambia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Stratified random sampling | TF, TS, TC, TT, CO | 1, 2 and 3 |
Medina et al., 199215 | Brazil | PBPS | School: children age 4–11 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma | 1, 2 and 3 |
Luna et al., 199216 | Brazil | PBPS | Community: children 1–10 years and people ≥ 10 years | Random sample of HHs | TF, TI, active trachoma, TS, TT | 3 |
Négrel et al., 199217 | Morocco | PBPS | Community: children < 10 years and women ≥ 15 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TI, TT | |
Katz et al., 199618 | Nepal | PBPS | Community: children 2–6 years | Systematic sampling | TF, TI, active trachoma | |
Zerihun N, 199719 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TS, TT, CO | 1 and 3 |
Dolin et al., 199820 | Gambia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TS, TT, CO | 1 and 3 |
Schémann et al., 199821 | Mali | PBPS | Community: children 0–10 years and women > 14 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TI, TT | |
Schémann et al., 200022 | Mali | TRA | Community: children < 10 years | Villages, then children in HHs | Active trachoma | |
Alene et al., 200023 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Full community census | Active trachoma | 1 and 3 |
Limburg et al., 200110 | Gambia | TRA | Community: children 1–10 years | Villages, then children in HHs | Active trachoma | |
Ezz al Arab et al., 200124 | Egypt | PBPS | Community: children 2–6 years and adults > 50 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, active trachoma, TT | |
Assefa et al., 200125 | Ethiopia | TRA | Community: all ages | Villages, then people in HHs | Active trachoma, TT | 2 |
Bejiga et al., 200126 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, TT | 4 |
Rabiu et al., 200127 | Nigeria | PBPS | Community: children 1–9 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma | 1 |
TRA | Community: children 1–9 years | Villages, then children within HHs | Active trachoma | |||
Lansingh et al., 200128 | Australia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Full community census | Active trachoma | 2 |
Paxton et al., 200129 | United Republic of Tanzania | PBPS | Community: children 1–10 years and women > 15 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TI, TT | 1 |
TRA | Community: children 1–10 years and women > 15 years | Villages then children within HHs | Active trachoma, TT | |||
Alves et al., 200130 | Brazil | PBPS | Community: all ages | Sampling method not described | Active trachoma, TS, TT | 1, 2 and 3 |
Liu et al., 200231 | China | PBPS | Community: children aged 1–10 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TT | 1 and 3 |
TRA | Community: children 1–10 years | Villages then children within HHs | Active trachoma | |||
Medina et al., 200232 | Brazil | PBPS | School: children aged 4–11 years | Stratified systematic sampling | TF, TI | |
Schémann et al., 200333 | Burkina Faso | PBPS | Community: children < 10 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma | 2 and 4 |
Saal et al., 200334 | Senegal | PBPS | Community: children < 10 years and women age > 14 years | Two stage CRS | Active trachoma, TI, TT | |
Wondimu et al., 200335 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: all ages | Two stage CRS | TT | 4 |
Madani et al., 200336 | Chad | PBPS | Community: children < 10 years and women > 14 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, TT | |
Myatt et al., 200312 | Malawi | ASTRA | Community: children 2–5 years | Selection of HHs by compact segment method | Active trachoma | 2 |
Regassa et al., 200437 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: adults > 15 years | Three stage CRS | TF, TI, active trachoma, TS, TT, CO | 2 and 4 |
Cumberland et al., 200538 | Ethiopia | PBPS | Community: children 3–9 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, active trachoma | 1 and 3 |
Myatt et al., 200539 | Viet Nam | ASTRA | School: children 6–11 years | Systematic sampling | Active trachoma | 2 |
Ngondi et al., 200540 | Sudan | PBPS | Community: children 1–9 years and adults ≥ 15 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, active trachoma, TS, TT, CO | |
Faye et al., 200541 | Senegal | ASTRA | Community: children 2–5 years and adults > 40 years | Two stage CRS | TF only, TF+TI, TI only | 2 |
Khandekar et al., 200642 | Viet Nam | PBPS | Community: adults ≥ 35 years | Two stage CRS | TS, TT, TCO | 4 |
Al-Khatib et al., 200643 | Yemen | TRA | Community: children 1–9 years | Villages, then people within HHs | Active trachoma, TT cases | 2 |
Karimurio et al., 200644 | Kenya | PBPS | Community: children 1–9 years and adults ≥15 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TT | 4 |
Ngondi et al., 200645 | Sudan | PBPS | Community: children 1–9 years and adults ≥ 15 years | Two stage CRS | TF, TI, active trachoma, TS, TT, CO |
ASTRA, acceptance sampling trachoma rapid assessment; CRS, cluster random survey; CO, corneal opacity; LQAS, lot quality-assurance sampling; HHs, households; PBPS, population-based prevalence survey; TF, trachomatous inflammation-follicular; TI, trachomatous inflammation-intense; TRA, trachoma rapid assessment; TS, trachomatous scarring; TT, trachomatous trichiasis. a Detailed summary of studies reviewed available from: http://www.cartercenter.org/news/publications/health/trachoma_experts.html b Active trachoma defined as TF and/or TI. c Problems with methods: (1) sample size calculation parameters not given, (2) examiner reliability not reported, (3) confidence intervals of prevalence estimates not reported and (4) adjustment for clustering of trachoma not reported.