Table 1.
Overview of general medical journal podcasts
Journal (Rank, impact factor)* | Frequency, approx length (range), accessibility | Format | Technical quality and listening experience | Link and other multimedia products | Adverts |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
NEJM (1, 52.589) Subscription required for journal | Every issue (weekly) since November 2005, 15–25 mins, free to access | Content: Summarizes articles in each issue – more recent podcasts also come with PowerPoint slidesPresentation: Single voice | Technical quality: OK but bit of an echoListening experience: dull | http://podcast.nejm.org/nejm_audio_summaries.xmlCurrent weekly issue available on homepage; past issue podcasts archived with contents page for each issue Podcast RSS feed available (most recent four only)Also available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: triallingBeta audio summary with slidesAlso offer ‘Value added services’ to subscription holders only (e.g. video and slideshow) | Yes (sponsored by pharma) |
Lancet (2, 28.638) Subscription required for journal | Every issue (weekly) since February 2006, 10 mins (4–42 mins), free to access | Content: Very brief overview of highlights followed by either featured article (interview with authors) or featured theme Presentation: Interview style | Technical quality: OK but bit of an echo and some interview lines slightly poorer quality (background hiss) Listening experience: Variety of voices/interview style more interesting and easier to follow | http://www.thelancet.com/audioAll accessible on single pagePodcast RSS feed availableAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: None | No |
JAMA (3, 25.547) Subscription required for journal | Every issue (weekly) since March 2006, 10mins (7–14 mins), free to access | Content: Editor gives detailed summary of main articles in the issue – then lists all the other content Presentation: Single voice narration | Technical quality: OK but bit of an echoListening experience: dull – monotonous voice with little intonation, difficult to tell when one article finished and next started | http://jama.ama-assn.org/misc/audiocommentary.dtlAll accessible on single pageAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: Range including Author in the room – teleconferences and video supplements | No |
Annals of Internal Medicine (4, 15.516) Subscription required for journal | Every issue (fortnightly) since July 2007, 20 mins (12–47 mins), free to access | Content: In-depth look at featured article – with interview, plus a summary of everything else Presentation: Uses music and interview style to add interest | Technical quality: OK but bit of an echo – background hiss on interviewsListening experience: Interview style/ voice easy to listen to/interesting | http://www.annals.org/podcast/All accessible on single pageFacility to record comments availablePodcast RSS feed availableAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: Video presentations on guidelines/key topics in Internal Medicine Reports | No |
BMJ (7, 9.723) Research articles free online | Periodically since September 2006 – recently about one a month, 10 mins (5–80 mins), free to access | Content: Interview or debate on key policy issues – not directly linked to BMJ issue content Presentation: Interviewer and key figure or debate panel | Technical quality: OK but bit of an echo and volume variable particularly in debatesListening experience: Style easy to listen to – dialogue makes it interesting | http://www.bmj.com/audio/All accessible on single pagePodcast RSS feed availableAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: Range of presentation types linked to CPD and other BMJ products | No |
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (14, 4.654) National subscription | Every issue (quarterly) since January 2008, 3 mins (2–5 mins), free to access | Content: Summary of quarterly update content then individual podcasts for each new/updated review; brief introduction followed by single voice narrationPresentation: Mostly one voice only, sometimes interview style | Technical quality: quality of recording variable; echo with intermittent background hiss Listening experience: Quality of presentation variable, sometimes stilted and amateurish; some accents difficult to follow | http://www.cochrane.org/podcasts/index.htm All accessible on single page together with a link direct to the relevant reviewOptions to bookmark or email the page offeredEmail contact for technical helpPodcast RSS feed availableAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: None | No |
Southern Medical Journal (62, 0.998) Subscription required for journal | Every issue (monthly) since April 2006 (discontinued March 2008), 10 mins (6–15 mins), free to access | Content: Very brief introduction followed by short summaries of featured content Presentation: Intro music and single voice narration | Technical quality: OK Listening experience: Delivery of content monotonous – essentially abstracts read aloud | http://www.sma.org/smj/podcasts/index.cfmAll accessible on single pagePodcast RSS feed availableAlso available via iTunesOther multimedia facilities offered: None | No |
Thomson. Journal Citation Reports®. 2007 JCR Science Edition (accessed November 2008)