Skip to main content
. 2007 Mar;61(3):262–270. doi: 10.1136/jech.2006.046110

Box 6 Included studies and appraisal checklists.

Study design Appraisal checklists
Randomised controlled trial (n = 3) SIGN and CASP
Cluster randomised controlled trial (n = 1) SIGN and CASP
Quasi‐randomised controlled trial (n = 3) SIGN and CASP
Retrospective case control study (n = 1) SIGN and CASP
Cross‐sectional study (n = 3) SIGN and NZGG
Non‐comparative descriptive study (n = 7) Reviewer checklist
Non‐comparative time series study (n = 1) Reviewer checklist
Qualitative study (n = 13) CASP and UKGCSRO

CASP, Critical appraisal skills programme41; SIGN, Scottish intercollegiate guidelines network42; NZGG, New Zealand guidelines group43; UKGCSRO, UK Government chief social researcher's office.44

Reviewer checklist included: purpose, population, response rate, outcome definition and assessment.