Table 4.
Comparison of GFR prediction equations using published coefficients and coefficients derived from training data set of 349 children of the CKiD studya
Model | Data Source | N | Ageb | Agent | GFRb | Equation for eGFR |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scr-based formulas | ||||||
Counahan et al.2 | Original | 108 | 0.2 to 14 (n = 103) | 51Cr-EDTA | 4 to 200 | 43.00[height/Scr] |
CKiD | 349 | 1.2 to 17.1 | Iohexol | 16 to 93 | 41.30[height/Scr] | |
Leger et al.35 | Original | 97 | 0.8 to 21 | 51Cr-EDTA | 97 (31 to 200) | 0.641[weight/Scr] + 16.063[height2/Scr] |
CKiD | 349 | 1.2 to 17.1 | Iohexol | 44 (16 to 93) | 0.542[weight/Scr] + 9.948[height2/Scr] | |
Cystatin C–based formulas | ||||||
Filler et al.36 | Original | 536 | 11.2 ± 4.5 | 99mTc-DTPA | 103 ± 41 | 91.62[1/CysC]1.123 |
CKiD | 349 | 10.6 ± 4.2 | Iohexol | 44 ± 15 | 66.22[1/CysC]0.777 | |
Grubb et al.27 | Original | 536 | <18 (n = 85) | Iohexol | 113, 99, 63c | 84.69[1/CysC]1.680[1.3841(age < 14)] |
CKiD | 349 | <18 | Iohexol | 41, 42, NAc | 68.06[1/CysC]0.781[0.9661(age < 14)] | |
Scr- and cystatin C–based formulas | ||||||
Bouvet et al.20 | Original | 100 | 1.4 to 22.8 | 51Cr-EDTA | 95 (18 to 200) | 63.2[1.2/CysC]0.56[(96/88.4)/(Scr)]0.35[weight/45]0.30[age/14]0.40 |
CKiD | 349 | 1.2 to 17.1 | Iohexol | 44 (16 to 93) | 46.1[1.2/CysC]0.33[(96/88.4)/(Scr)]0.55[weight/45]0.77[age/14]0.17 | |
Zappitelli et al.21 | Original | 103 | 12.7 ± 4.7 | Iothalamate | 74 ± 36 | 43.82[1/CysC]0.635[1/Scr]0.547[1.35height] |
CKiD | 349 | 10.6 ± 4.2 | Iohexol | 44 ± 15 | 25.38[1/CysC]0.331[1/Scr]0.602[1.88height] |
GFR, ml/min per 1.73 m2; eGFR, ml/min per 1.73 m2, except Leger's and Bouvet's in ml/min; height, m; Scr, mg/dl; CysC, cystatin C, mg/L; weight, kg.
Descriptive statistics (e.g., range, mean ± SD) for CKiD sample are those reported in the original publications.
Medians for age <14, 14 to <18, ≥18 yr.