Table 7.
Comparation of the results of NHBD/HBD in England relating to primary non-function, delayed graft function and acute rejection.
| Author | NHBD/HBD | PNF(%)NHBD/HBD | DGF(%)NHBD/HBD | AR(%)NHBD/HBD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nicholson et al25 | 30/114 | 3/13(s) | 25/87(s) | 48/27(s) |
| Butterworth et al26 | 37/91 | 11/1(s) | 100/28(s) | 27/36(ns) |
| Nicholson et al27 | 77/224 | 9.1/2.7(s) | 84.3/21(s) | 28.6/32.6(ns) |
| Balupuri et al21 | 15/nm | 6.6/- | 66.6/- | nm |
| Balupuri et al28 | 28/nm | 3.57/- | 91.6/- | nm |
| Metcalfe et al29 | 72/192 | 7/4(ns) | 80/19(s) | 24/31(ns) |
| Gok et al30 | 43/nm | - | - | - |
| Gerstenkorn et al31 | 202/nm | 21.8/- | 82.3/- | 13.1/- |
| Gok et al32 | 46/46 | 8.7/2.2 | 94.9/41(s) | 52.2/41.3(ns) |
| Sudhindran et al23 | 42/84 | 0/2 | 50/17(s) | 33.3/40.5(ns) |
| Gok et al33 | 25/nm | 2/nm | 75/nm | - |
| Brook et al 34 | 55/69 | 5/3 | 93/17 | 24/23(ns) |
| Gerstenkorn et al35 | 41/0 | 14.6 | 80 | - |
| Gok et al36 | 72/nm | 7.85/- | 75.6/- | 41.4/- |
| Brook et al37 | 285/0 | 15 | 79.7 | 41 |
| Gok et al38 | 2/0 | 0/0 | 100/0 | 100/0 |
| Wilson et al39 | 51/nm | 2/nm | 7/nm | - |
| Bains et al40 | 37/75 | 0/0 | 31/8(s) | 7/27(ns) |
| Navarro et al41 | 81/- | nm | nm | nm |
| Gok et al42 | 19/15 | nm | 57.9/45.5(s) | 36.8/20(s) |
| Navarro et al43 | 5/- | nm | nm | nm |
| Sohrabi et al44 | 5/- | 0/- | 80/- | nm |
| Sohrabi et al45 | 36/- | 6.3/- | nm | 35/- |
| Muiesan et al46 | 07/0 | 0 | 0 | 3 |
s-significant; ns- not statistically significant; nm- not mentioned; nhbd-non-heart-beating donor;hbd-heart-beating donor; pnf-primary non-function;dgf-delayed graft function;ar-acute rejection.