Table 1. Performan ce of simulated models for CBT treatment for Suicide.

Simulated Based on Heterogeneity for Defiers compared to other 3 groups
	True Value	Coverage	Mean Bias	Pct Bias	MSE
Direct Effect
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-5.70	96.2% 95.3%	-0.38 -0.06%	-6.6% -1.1%	8.07 3.91
Homogeneous Model	-5.70	97.4% 97.8%	-0.60 -0.30	-10.4% -5.2%	9.80 5.46
Direct Effect within Always Mediators
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-10.05	97.6% 97.9%	1.89 0.76	18.7% 7.6%	47.22 24.32
Homogeneous Model	-10.05	97.6% 99.8%	5.06 4.38	50.1% 43.3%	31.30 29.90
Direct Effect within Never Mediators
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-4.96	95.0% 95.3%	-0.79 -0.24	-15.8% -4.8%	9.65 4.66
Homogeneous Model	-4.96	95.0% 95.5%	-1.63 -1.24	-32.5% -24.9%	11.83 6.56

Mis-specifed Model - Simulation based on Heterogeneity for Always Mediators compared to other 3 groups
	True Value	Coverage	Mean Bias	Pct Bias	MSE
Direct Effect
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-5.70	96.4% 92.8%	0.74 0.74	12.9% 12.9%	10.09 5.46
Homogeneous Model	-5.70	95.6% 94.4%	0.69 1.24	12.0% 21.6%	13.16 9.50
Direct Effect within Always Mediators
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-10.05	47.4% 36.7%	15.53 16.50	153.7% 163.3%	39.12 25.36
Homogeneous Model	-10.05	80.8% 78.9%	10.78 11.65	106.8% 115.3%	39.38 39.37
Direct Effect within Never Mediators
Heterogeneous by Defiers Model	-4.96	92.8% 89.9%	-1.42 -1.57	-28.4% -31.4%	11.81 5.93
Homogeneous Model	-4.96	95.2% 93.2%	-0.67 -0.03	-13.5% -0.7%	15.13 10.46

Note: Per row top number corresponds to results for N=101 and bottom corresponds to results for N=202.