Table 1.
Summary of the various antioxidants studied for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
Disease | Test agent | Primary endpoint | Result/Outcome | Model | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ALS | Vitamin E, Synthetic porphyrins | Motor neuron architecture, 3-NT and malondialdehyde in spinal cord | Therapeutic benefit with improved survival | Mouse | 37 |
AEOL 10150, riluzole | Onset, progression of disease and overall lifespan | Delayed disease onset and progression and did not prolong survival | Mouse | 59 | |
NDGA | Nitrite release, gliosis | Improved life-span and motor dysfunction | Mouse | 164 | |
Celecoxib | PGE-2 release, rate of change in upper extremity motor function |
Mouse studies: Inhibition of PGE-2 production in the spinal cord with prolonged survival. Human studies: No improvements in motor dysfunction, muscle strength and no adverse effects |
Mouse Human |
39, 43 | |
Single or mixture of antioxidants | Meta-analysis from nine studies: Post-12 month treatment survival | Lack of any significant beneficial effects for antioxidants used alone or in combination | Human | 109 |
3-NT: 3-nitrotyrosine; NDGA: nordihydroguairetic acid; PGE-2: prostaglandin E-2.