Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Comput Med Imaging Graph. 2009 Jan 3;33(2):148–153. doi: 10.1016/j.compmedimag.2008.11.002

Table 3.

Evaluation of border detection methods (b: benign, m: melanoma)

Ref. # Experts # Images (Distr.) # Comp. Error Measure (Value)

[12] 3 90 (65 b / 25 m) 4 XOR (10.63%)
[16] 1 67 0 XOR (14.63%)
[9] 1 100 (70 b / 30 m) 3 XOR (2.73%)
[26] 1 50 2 Error prob. (16%)
[26] 1 50 2 Error prob. (21%)
[19] 2 100 (70 b / 30 m) 3 XOR (12.02%)
[21] 5 319 (244 b / 75 m) 1 Prec. (94.1%) & Rec. (95.2%)
[20] nr 117 3 Sens. (95%) & Spec. (96%)
[27] 2 100 (70 b / 30 m) 1 XOR (15.59%)
[28] 0 nr 0 nr
[29] 0 600 0 Visual
[30] 0 nr 0 nr
[31] 5 30 0 Visual
[32] 1 30 0 Visual
[11] 1 400 0 Visual
[33] 1 300 0 Visual
[34] 1 57 5 XOR (36.50%)
[34] 1 57 5 XOR (24.71%)