Skip to main content
. 2007 Sep;92(5):F391–F398. doi: 10.1136/adc.2006.106419

Table 2 Characteristics of reporting systems.

Reference What is reported? Reporting climate Area of reporting Reporter Characteristics of report form Review/analysis of reports Systems‐oriented52 Time until feedback(months)
Folli50 USA 1987 Errant medication order: ordering physician and pharmacist agreed on the need to change the order Not described Paediatric wards including NICU Pharmacist reviews all medication orders and reports all errant orders Type of medication order Patient age Severity Unit in which patient received the order Member of the paediatric faculty or attending physician Two paediatric clinical pharmacist practitioners >3
Vincer47 Canada 1989 Medication incidents Incident has reached the patient (except for errors of omission). Non‐punitive Voluntary NICU Either self reported or reported by another person who identified incident Type of incident Patient information and severity Cause of incident Time Committee of three:Neonatologist Nursing unit coordinator Clinical neonatal pharmacist +/− <1
Raju39 USA 1989 Medication errors Medication dose must reach the patient, except for errors of omission (criteria by American Society of Hospital Pharmacists, 1988) Non‐punitive Anonymous Voluntary NICU/PICU ICU staff, person who noticed the error Type Severity Error attribution Time Manager from the pharmacy department Department of quality assurance ? <1
Frey23 Switzerland 2000 Overall critical incident monitoring Critical incident: any event which might have reduced, or did reduce, the safety margin for the patient Non‐punitive Anonymous Voluntary NICU/PICU ICU staff fills out form immediately on becoming aware of a critical incident Narrative, including contributing factors Patient information and severity Incident attributionTime and location Critical incident group:Two nurses One consultant + 1–3
Ross51 UK 2000 Medication error: wrong medicine, wrong dose, wrong route, wrong preparation, wrong time, unauthorised drug or omission, wrong dispensing, or to someone known to be allergic Gradual change from punitive to non‐punitive Mandatory Paediatric wards, including NICU Hospital‐wide reporting, all staff Standardised form in all departments Not further specified Head of department + 1–3
Kaushal15 USA 2001 Medication errors and (potential) (intercepted) ADEs. An ADE is an injury that results from a drug. A preventable ADE is an ADE associated with a medication error Non‐punitive Non‐anonymous Voluntary Paediatric wards including NICU House officers, nurses and pharmacists report verbally to trained data collectors Type of error Name, dose, route and category of drug Point in system where error occurred Two physicians(severity, preventability and attribution were recorded) + <1
Frey24 Switzerland 2002 Drug related critical incidents A critical incident is a harmful and potentially harmful event Non‐punitive Anonymous Voluntary NICU/PICU ICU staff fill out form immediately on becoming aware of a critical incident Narrative, including contributing factors Patient information and severity Time and location Was patient harm prevented by check?Proposals for prevention Were patient/parents informed? Quality assurance group:One consultant Three senior nurses One teaching nurse One junior nurse One person responsible for ICU equipment + 1–3
Simpson41 UK 2004 Medication errors identified through critical incident reports Non‐punitive NICU Nursing or medical staff involved in the error, or the clinical pharmacist Not specified Risk management group:Clinical pharmacist Consultant neonatologist Neonatal specialist registrar Senior nurse(severity was recorded) + <1
Suresh43 USA 2004 Errors that resulted in harm to the patient as well as near misses Non‐punitive Anonymous Voluntary NICU 739 Healthcare providers (physicians, nurses, pharmacists and others) from a total of 54 NICUs were authorised to report to hypertext mark‐up language forms External, internet based Phase 1: 4 free text boxes (title, description, key words, references)Phase 2: structured scroll‐down form:severity, time and location, type, contributing and mitigating factors, changes to prevent recurrence Members of Center for Patient Safety in neonatal intensive care + <1
Kanter14 USA 2004 Medical error: International Classification of Diseases (ICD)‐9 diagnosis codes 996–999 (complications of medical or surgical care) Not specified Hospital discharge data of neonates Not specified Discharge records with diagnostic, utilisation and patient information Healthcare Cost and Utilisation Project of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Not specified