Supplementary Table 2.
Comparison with other RCC studies.
Method | number of samples/microarray platform | Final number of genes | Overlap with 158 marker genes | Overlap with 64* marker-genes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Young et al. 2001 | More than two-fold changed in two or more tumor samples | 7 tumor (4 cc-RCC), 7 normal/cDNA 7,075 genes | 189 | 8 | 1 |
Takahashi et al. 2001 | Three-fold or more changed in 75% or more of the tumor samples | 29 cc-RCC and 29 normal/cDNA 21,632 genes | 109 | 7 | - |
Gieseg et al. 2002 | Changed genes in cc-RCC with Wilcoxon test p-value ≤0.001 and fold change ≥1.1 | 13 RCC (9cc-RCC), 9 normal/ Affymetrix 5600 genes | 355 genes, 85 reported | 4 | 1 |
Boer et al. 2001 | adapted sign test by counting for each gene the number of times that its measured intensity in the set of repeated pair-wise comparisons is higher in T and N | 37 cc-RCC, 37 normal | 1738 cDNAs | 45 | 11 |
Higgins et al. 2003 | No reported gene set; selected genes with avg fold change >3 and t-test p-value >0.03. | 41 RCC (23 cc-RCC), 3 normal/cDNA 22,648 genes | 182 genes | 8 | 1 |
Jones et al. 2005 | 90% lower confidence boung of the fold change was >2 and t-test p-value <0.001 | 8 clear cell stage I, 23 normal, Affymetrix 22,283 genes | 1359 up-regulated, 493 down-regulated | 37 up, 19 down-regulated | 15 up-regulated |
Sultmann et al. 2005 | t-test with estimated false discovery rate <0.23 | 25 ccRCC, 25 normal/RCC-specific cDNA microarrays with 4207 genes | 620 up-regulated; 561 down-regulated genes | 13 up, 11 down-regulated | 5 up, 2 down-regulated |
genes not identified by Lenburg et al.