Skip to main content
. 2009 May 18;4(5):e5591. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005591

Table 4. Compliance with the 12 methodologic criteria in seven case-control studies.

First Author Baker JA Møller H Doria-Rose VP Swerdlow AJ Forman D PM Haughey BP Brown LM
Year (Ref. No.) 2005 (9) 1999 (10) 2005 (11) 1989 (12) 1994 (18) 1989 (19) 1987 (20)
Predetermined method + + + + + + +
Specification of the agent + + + + + + +
Unbiased data collection ± ± + ± ±
Anamnestic eauivalence + ± + ± ± ±
Avoidance of constrained cases + + + + + + +
Avoidance of constrained controls + + + + + + +
Equal diagnostic examination + +
Equal diagnostic surveillance
Equal demographic susceptibility + + + ± + + +
Equal clinical susceptibility + + + + +
Avoidance of protopathic bias
Community control for Berkson's bias + + + +

+, positive; −, negative; ±, uncertain; △, not applicable or not evaluable.