Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2009 May 11.
Published in final edited form as: Bayesian Anal. 2008 Jul 1;3(3):585–614. doi: 10.1214/08-BA323

Table 5.

The Top Five Models Based on PMP, DIC, LPML, and L Measure for Chapman Data

a0 = 0.001 a0 = 0.01 a0 = 0.1 a0 = 0.5 a0 = 1.0
Criterion Mk Values Mk Values Mk Values Mk Values Mk Values
PMP M2 0.57 M2 0.25 M22 0.14 M22 0.07 M22 0.06
M1 0.11 M10 0.23 M10 0.14 M10 0.07 M10 0.05
M5 0.07 M9 0.08 M9 0.06 M29 0.05 M19 0.04
M10 0.07 M22 0.08 M2 0.06 M19 0.05 M29 0.04
M6 0.06 M16 0.07 M16 0.06 M30 0.05 M21 0.04
DIC M22 142.83 M22 142.67 M22 144.74 M22 165.65 M22 186.77
M10 143.79 M10 143.70 M10 145.70 M10 166.02 M10 186.88
M30 144.85 M29 144.74 M29 146.43 M29 166.42 M30 187.10
M29 144.96 M30 144.78 M30 146.48 M19 166.87 M21 187.38
M21 145.63 M21 145.59 M21 147.29 M30 166.90 M20 187.75
LPML M2 −73.38 M2 −73.30 M32 −73.79 M32 −83.10 M30 −93.29
M5 −73.56 M5 −73.50 M2 −74.11 M29 −83.32 M32 −93.35
M4 −73.58 M6 −73.55 M7 −74.43 M10 −83.34 M21 −93.41
M6 −73.73 M4 −73.64 M8 −74.48 M19 −83.55 M10 −93.41
M32 −73.91 M3 −73.65 M9 −74.68 M21 −83.56 M20 −93.55
L
ν = 0.1		 M22 21.47 M22 21.98 M22 26.96 M22 38.92 M30 45.21
M30 22.04 M25 22.63 M25 27.33 M25 38.99 M22 45.23
M26 22.13 M30 22.64 M30 27.41 M29 39.02 M26 45.26
M32 22.15 M29 22.65 M26 27.45 M19 39.16 M20 45.28
M10 22.21 M10 22.67 M29 27.47 M10 39.18 M21 45.31
L
ν = 0.25		 M22 24.79 M22 25.29 M22 30.23 M22 42.56 M30 49.39
M30 25.17 M32 25.69 M32 30.56 M29 42.61 M22 49.45
M32 25.17 M30 25.77 M30 30.56 M25 42.67 M20 49.49
M10 25.43 M29 25.78 M29 30.62 M32 42.73 M26 49.51
M20 25.47 M10 25.89 M25 30.65 M19 42.79 M21 49.52
L
ν = 0.5		 M32 30.20 M32 30.73 M32 35.66 M29 48.59 M30 56.36
M22 30.31 M22 30.80 M22 35.70 M32 48.62 M32 56.47
M30 30.38 M30 30.98 M30 35.81 M22 48.64 M22 56.50
M20 30.77 M29 31.00 M29 35.88 M30 48.78 M20 56.50
M10 30.80 M10 31.26 M10 36.10 M25 48.79 M21 56.55
L
ν = 0.75		 M32 35.24 M32 35.76 M32 40.77 M32 54.52 M30 63.33
M30 35.59 M30 36.20 M30 41.06 M29 54.56 M32 63.41
M22 35.84 M29 36.22 M29 41.14 M22 54.71 M20 63.52
M29 36.04 M22 36.31 M22 41.16 M30 54.78 M22 63.54
M20 36.08 M10 36.63 M10 41.48 M19 54.88 M21 63.57
L
ν = 0.9		 M32 38.26 M32 38.78 M32 43.83 M32 58.06 M30 67.51
M30 38.72 M30 39.33 M30 44.21 M29 58.15 M32 67.58
M22 39.16 M29 39.35 M29 44.29 M22 58.36 M20 67.73
M29 39.17 M22 39.61 M22 44.44 M30 58.37 M22 67.77
M20 39.26 M27 39.83 M10 44.70 M19 58.51 M21 67.79