Table 1.
Studies in which measures of nonspeech oral motor (NS) and speech performance (S) have been compared in individuals with a various neurological disorders. A positive finding is indicated by a plus, a negative by a minus, and both signed indicates mixed findings. Studies are listed in chronological order.
Study | Patient Type | Finding | Summary |
---|---|---|---|
Hixon & Hardy50 | Cerebral Palsy | − |
NS: Nonspeech AMR, Speech DDK S: scaled speech defectiveness |
LaPointe & Wertz51 | Brain Injury | − |
NS: Isolated oral movements, oro-motor sequencing tasks S: severity of articulatory defectiveness |
Dworkin, Aronson, & Mulder52 | Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis | + |
NS: Tongue force S: articulatory defectiveness |
Barlow & Abbs 53,54 | Cerebral Palsy | + |
NS: Jaw + tongue + lip force stability S: speech intelligibility |
Dworkin & Aronson55 | Various | − |
NS: Tongue strength, speech DDK S: scaled intelligibility |
DePaul & Brooks56 | Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis | −/+ |
NS: Speed of tongue or lower lip force production S: scaled speech severity |
Langmore & Lehman57 | Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis | −/+ |
NS: Maximum (nonspeech) repetition rates of lips, tongue, jaw S: scaled speech severity |
McHenry, Minton, Wilson, & Post58 | Traumatic Brain Injury | − |
NS: Oro-facial force S: speech intelligibility |
Solomon et al.59 | Parkinson Disease | − |
NS: Lingual fatigue S: speaking rate |
Solomon et al.60 | Parkinson Disease | −/+ |
NS: Tongue strength S: severity of speech defectiveness |
Thompson, Murdoch, & Stokes61 | Upper Motor Neuron Disease | − |
NS: Tongue strength S: perceptual ratings of articulatory performance |
Thompson, Murdoch, & Stokes62 | Upper Motor Neuron Disease | − |
NS: Lip force, vowel or consonant precision S: speech intelligibility |
Theodoros, Murdoch, & Stokes63 | Traumatic Brain Injury | − |
NS: Lip and tongue strength S: perceptual rating of severity |
Solomon, Robin, & Luschei64 | Parkinson Disease | − |
NS: Tongue strength and endurance S: articulatory precision and speech defectiveness |