Table 1.
Examples of different categories of group decisions.
| social sciences | natural sciences | |
|---|---|---|
| groups with global overview | ||
| decision category: interactive/combined decisions | ||
| group decision | democratic/parliamentary votes | group activity synchronization |
| perspective | voting strategies | who decides and why? |
| references | Austen-Smith & Feddersen (2009), Hix et al. (2009) and many more | Conradt & Roper (2003, 2007, 2009), Rands et al. (2003) and Dostalkova & Spinka (2007) |
| group decision | common goods | movements in small groups |
| perspective | individual strategies | who decides and how? |
| references | Gächter & Herrmann (2009) and many more | Stewart & Harcourt (1994), Gompper (1996), Conradt & Roper (2005), Amé et al. (2006), Biro et al. (2006), Meunier et al. (2006), Fischhoff et al. (2007) and Sueur & Petit (2008) |
| group decision | international agreements | cooperative breeding |
| perspective | strategies | individual strategies |
| references | a large body of literature | Clutton-Brock (1998) |
| decision category: aggregate/consensus decisions | ||
| group decision | international agreements | group activity synchronization |
| perspective | patterns | segregation |
| references | a large body of literature | Conradt (1998), Ruckstuhl (1998, 1999), Conradt & Roper (2000), Ruckstuhl & Neuhaus (2000, 2002) and List (2004) |
| group decision | democratic/parliamentary votes | movements in small groups |
| perspective | systems | outcomes, speed, accuracy |
| references | a large body of literature | List (2004), Trillmich et al. (2004), Kerth et al. (2006), Gautrais et al. (2007), Sumpter et al. (2008) and Ward et al. (2008) |
| group decision | military orders or hierarchical decisions | cooperative hunting |
| perspective | any | patterns |
| references | Courchamp et al. (2002) | |
| self-organizing systems | ||
| decision category: interactive/combined decisions | ||
| group decision | consumer choice | movements in large groups |
| perspective | how do consumers make choices? | mechanisms, individual strategies |
| references | a large body of literature | Selous (1931), Gueron et al. (1996), Prins (1996), Couzin & Krause (2003), Couzin et al. (2005), Ballerini et al. (2008), Hemelrijk & Hildenbrandt (2008), Conradt & Roper (2009) and Conradt et al. (in press) |
| group decision | traffic movements | job allocation in eusocial insects |
| perspective | individual behaviours | individual decisions |
| references | Couzin & Krause (2003) and Ishaque & Noland (2008) | Beshers & Fewell (2001) |
| group decision | panic behaviour in crowds | nest choice in eusocial insects |
| perspective | individual strategies | behaviour of individual scouts |
| references | Aube & Shield (2004) | Seeley & Buhrman (1999), Franks et al. (2009), List et al. (2009) and Sumpter & Pratt (2009) |
| decision category: aggregate/consensus decisions | ||
| group decision | consumer choice | movements in large groups |
| perspective | market prices | speed, accuracy, patterns |
| references | a large body of literature | Wallraff (1978), Krause et al. (1992), Reebs (2000), Couzin & Krause (2003), Simons (2004), Couzin et al. (2005), Buhl et al. (2006) and Dyer et al. (2009) |
| group decision | panic behaviour in crowds | nest choice in eusocial insects |
| perspective | evacuation time | decision speed and accuracy |
| references | Helbing et al. (2000) | List et al. (2009) and Sumpter & Pratt (2009) |