Table 4.
Options for minimizing dengue risk in the blood supply
Strategies | Endemic countries | Non-endemic countries |
---|---|---|
No specific measures taken for dengue | Risk of transfusion-transmitted dengue increased, dependent on prevalence in donor population and proportion of donors with asymptomatic infection | Risk of transfusion-transmitted dengue low, dependent on proportion of donor population who may recently be exposed to dengue infection through travel |
No direct cost to blood service, but indirect cost from patient morbidity from transfusion-transmitted infection and loss of confidence in blood supply safety | No direct cost to blood service, but indirect cost from loss of confidence in blood supply safety in event of a transfusion-transmitted infection occurring | |
Donor qualification – deferral of at-risk donors, e.g. symptoms of fever, travel history, exposure to dengue patients, etc. | Deferral based on exposure not feasible when disease is endemic, unable to exclude early and asymptomatic infection | Deferral based on exposure feasible, able to reduce risk of accepting donations from early and asymptomatic infected donors |
Nonspecific, leads to high donor loss | Low donor loss, dependent on proportion of donor population likely to travel to endemic countries | |
Low cost-effectiveness | Cost-effective | |
NAT testing of donations for dengue | Able to detect asymptomatic infection | Able to detect asymptomatic infection |
Donor loss dependent on specificity of test system | Donor loss dependent on specificity of test system | |
Expensive | Expensive | |
Cost-effectiveness depends on prevalence of asymptomatic infected donors | Low cost-effectiveness | |
Pathogen reduction | Able to reduce transmission risks | Able to reduce transmission risks |
Expensive and only available for platelets and plasma currently. May result in reduced product yields | Expensive and only available for platelets and plasma currently. May result in reduced product yields | |
Low cost-effectiveness for dengue alone | Low cost-effectiveness for dengue alone | |
Increased cost-effectiveness depends on ability to reduce risks of other transfusion-transmitted diseases as well | Increased cost-effectiveness depends on ability to reduce risks of other transfusion-transmitted diseases as well |