Table 4.
Results of sensitivity analyses assuming lower sensitivity and higher specificity for CBE, and assuming an alternative treatment distribution. Costs and QALYs are discounted at 3%. Dominated strategies are indicated with ’—’
Assuming lower sensitivity and higher specificity for CBE |
Assuming alternative survival model | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Strat | Total Cost ($) |
QALYs (years) |
Incremental QALYs gained |
ICER | Strat | Total Cost ($) |
QALYs (years) |
Incremental QALYs gained |
ICER |
X | 13,100 | 27.3944 | X | 13,000 | 27.4158 | ||||
B | 14,300 | 27.4239 | — | — | A | 14,300 | 27.4427 | 0.0270 | 46,900 |
A | 14,300 | 27.4265 | 0.0321 | 36,900 | B | 14,300 | 27.4396 | — | — |
D | 14,700 | 27.4288 | — | — | C | 14,600 | 27.4448 | 0.0021 | 152,100 |
C | 14,700 | 27.4331 | 0.0067 | 58,600 | D | 14,700 | 27.4450 | — | — |
E | 14,900 | 27.4317 | — | — | E | 15,000 | 27.4449 | — | — |
F | 15,100 | 27.4335 | — | — | F | 15,200 | 27.4459 | — | — |
G | 15,100 | 27.4345 | — | — | G | 15,200 | 27.4466 | 0.0018 | 339,400 |
H | 15,300 | 27.4357 | — | — | H | 15,300 | 27.4465 | — | — |
I | 15,400 | 27.4359 | 0.0028 | 250,200 | I | 15,500 | 27.4470 | 0.0005 | 611,800 |
J | 20,800 | 27.4376 | 0.0016 | 3,293,300 | J | 21,000 | 27.4480 | 0.0009 | 5,847,100 |
MM=Mammography; CBE=Clinical breast exam; intv=time interval between examinations (in years)
Total Cost: Mean total cost per woman in the complete cohort, rounded to the nearest $100
QALYs: Mean total expected quality-adjusted life years per woman from age 20 in the complete cohort
ICER: Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (incremental cost/incremental QALYs gained compared to next least-expensive strategy)
Current recommended strategies are shown in boldface: A=NCI/USPSTF; C=NCI; I=NCI/USPSTF; J=ACS