Table 3.
A. Using assumed attack rate |
B. Using documented attack rate |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|
PAR estimate from WHO |
PAR estimate from Snow et al. |
PAR estimate from WHO |
PAR estimate from Snow et al. |
|
Scenario 1 | ||||
Average annual number of malaria episodes | 13,190,503 | 7,614,310 | 7,650,492 | 1,921,851 |
Average annual number of severe cases | 659,525 | 380,715 | 382,525 | 96,093 |
Average annual number of deaths (range) | 164,881–329,763 | 95,179–190,358 | 95,631–191,262 | 24,023–48,046 |
Scenario 2 b | ||||
Average annual number of malaria episodes | 10,792,230 | 6,229,890 | 6,259,493 | 1,572,424 |
Average annual number of severe cases | 485,650 | 280,345 | 281,677 | 70,759 |
Average annual number of deaths (range) | 109,271–218,543 | 63,078–126,155 | 63,377–126,755 | 15,921–31,842 |
Scenario 3 c | ||||
Average annual number of malaria episodes | 15,247,000 | 9,306,379 | 9,350,601 | 2,348,929 |
Average annual number of severe cases | 838,585 | 511,851 | 514,283 | 129,191 |
Average annual number of deaths (range) | 230,611–461,222 | 140,759–281,518 | 141,428– 282,856 | 35,528– 71,055 |
Calculations are repeated using (A) the assumed average annual attack used by Worrall et al. [5], and (B) the median average annual attack rate reported in this review. Scenario 1 uses similar assumptions to those used by WHO for its own burden calculations. These assumptions have been altered in Scenarios 2 and 3 to reflect more ‘optimistic’ and ‘pessimistic’ situations by altering only the frequency of epidemics and the clinical attack rate associated with them.
Scenario 2 incorporates a 10% decrease in epidemic frequency and clinical attack rate over scenario 1
Scenario 3 incorporates a 10% increase in epidemic frequency and clinical attack rate over scenario 1