Table 10.
Author and date | Type of study/data source |
Population (denominator)/size |
Level of severity | Epidemiological observation | Major findings | Epidemiological shortcomings |
Ekman et al., 2007 [79] | descriptive study/National Statistical Offices; WHO database | general population/98150 Sweden (Boras); 65841 Latvia (Jelgava); 378913 Lithuania (Kaunas); 101140 Estonia (Tartu) Sweden, Baltic States |
deaths | rates by gender, crude and standardized, yearly, 3 y average; trends of mortality rates | 1990–2002 mortality rates per 100,000: 38 (Boras)/101 (Tartu)/112 (Jelgava)/126 (Kaunas); stable trends in Sweden, increasing rates until 1994, seamed to stabilized after 1997 in Baltic communities; higher rates in males vs. females and in age group under 65 y old in the Baltic communities than in Boras, Sweden. | Data on death only |
Buschmann et al., 2008 [86] | descriptive study/German trauma registry | general population (0–55 y) Germany |
deaths, hospitalization and A&E |
proportions by age, gender, body region, cause, process of care (e.g., length of stay) outcome (died/alive) | 1997–2003 children 3% of all patients multiple injured 0–15 y: 61% boys vs. 39% girls; over 70% head injuries 0–55 y: 41.3% RTC, 59.5% thorax injuries |
No population based rates, only injuries ISS>16; data focused on children |
Tiret et al., 1989 [83] | descriptive study/Hospitals data; deaths certificates | general population/2.7 million Aquitaine, France |
deaths, hospitalization | proportions by severity (ISS), cause, type, outcome (eight days still hospitalised/died in hospital); rates by age, gender, cause; non-fatal/fatal rate ratio | 1985/1986 136/10,000 all injury incidence rate; 40% falls, 27% traffic accidents, 15% poisonings Origin: suicide 14%, assault or homicide 3%, 82% others |
1 year study and one administrative region only |
Di Bartolomeo et al., 2004 [78] |
descriptive (prospective)study/Friuli Venezia Giulia regional registry |
general population/1.2 million Friuli Venezia Giulia Italy |
deaths, hospitalization | proportions by age, gender, cause, severity (ISS), process of care (e.g., timing), outcome (died/alive), rates by severity | 1998/1999 238 per mil per year mortality rate; 522 per mil per year incidence rate for severe injuries (ISS>15 & pre-hospital deaths); 98.2% blunt injury 81% RTC, 9.1% falls |
Only injuries ISS >15; 1 year study and one geographical region only (excludes self inflicted injuries) |
Plasencia & Borell 1996 [82] |
cross sectional survey/A&E Hospitals questionnaire data; City Death Registry | adults (>14 y)/1.7 million Barcelona; 6 million Catalonia, Spain | deaths, hospitalization and A&E | proportions by age, gender, cause, severity (ISS), type, location; rates age, gender, cause, location; case admission ratio | 1990/1991 7470/100,000 all injury rate 1.4 times higher rates in males vs. females, falls as a leading cause; 56/100,000 mortality rate 2 times higher in males vs. females; traffic injuries as leading cause; 4% of all injuries have ISS>8; 1 death:6 admissions:133 A&E |
No population based rates of major trauma (ISS>15, 1 year study, and one geographical region only; analysis based on extrapolated data on injuries |
Petridou et al., 2004 [80] | descriptive study/Questionnaire data; A&E Injury Surveillance System | adults (>15 y) Greece |
hospitalisation, A&E | proportions by age, gender, type; rates by gender, event timing (injury in relation to the interview date) | 2001 5.9 per 100 person-year incidence reported within a survey vs. 12.9 per 100 person-year incidence reported from the surveillance system | Major injuries defined as those requiring health care; 1 y study |