Table 3.
Author Country Year Follow-up Time |
Sample Size |
Baseline Age |
Population source |
Measure of weight |
Measure of Sleep | Potential Confounders Addressed |
Cross-sectional Relationship | Longitudinal Relationship |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Agras37 USA 2004 6.5 years | 150 | 3 | Birth cohort from San Francisco | Measured BMI | 1 sleep question to parents each year over 3 years | Age, ethnicity, SES, physical activity, TV viewing, diet, breastfeeding, eating behaviors, birthweight, parental obesity, parental attitudes towards eating and weight, temperatment, parental age | Not assessed. | Short SD associated with increased overweight risk. |
Hasler38 Switzerland 2004 13 years | 496 | 27 | Zurich Cohort Study | Reported BMI | 3 sleep questions (bedtime, wake-time, and sleep latency) at 4 time points | Age, sex, smoking, SES, physical activity, eating behaviors, parental obesity, depression | Short SD associated with increased obesity risk. | Short SD associated with increased obesity risk. |
Gangwisch6 USA 2005 9 years | 9,588 | 32–86 | NHANES | Measured & reported BMI | 1 sleep question | Age, sex, ethnicity, smoking, alcohol, SES, physical activity, depression, insomnia, sleepiness | U-shaped association between SD and obesity risk. | Short SD associated with increased obesity risk. |
Reilly36 UK 2005 4 years | 8,234 | 3 | ALSPAC | Measured BMI | 1 sleep question to parents | Age, sex, maternal smoking, SES, TV viewing, diet, birthweight, parental obesity | Not assessed. | Short SD associated with increased obesity risk. |
Patel3 USA 2006 16 years | 68,183 | 45–65 | Nurses Health Study | Reported BMI | 1 sleep question | Age, sex, smoking, alcohol, caffeine, SES, physical activity, diet, medical disorders, OSA, shiftwork, menopause, medications | U-shaped association between SD and obesity risk. | Short SD associated with increased obesity and weight gain risk. |
All estimates provided with 95% confidence intervals in parentheses. BMI: body mass index; SD: sleep duration; OR: odds ratio; HR: hazard ratio; NHANES: National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; ALSPAC: Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children; SES: socioeconomic status; TV: television; OSA: obstructive sleep apnea.