Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Appl Dev Psychol. 2009 May 1;30(3):321–331. doi: 10.1016/j.appdev.2008.12.018
Mother behavior items Definition and examples
Positive affect Caregiver demonstrates positive affect and emotional tone towards the child
through facial expression (smiles, laughter), gestures (hugging), and voice.
Positive verbal Caregiver makes encouraging statements of approval and affirmation towards
the child, including praise and acknowledgement (e.g., “Good job!; I know it
is difficult”), and other forms of positive reinforcement.
Responsiveness Caregiver replies to child's verbal statements, questions, and nonverbal
behaviors with contingent and appropriate responses. Examples include
responding to the child's requests for help, handing over objects out of the
child's reach as the child looks toward them, providing instructions that are
keyed into the child's current focus and responsive to the child's initiations.
Participation Caregiver is highly engaged with the child during the task, as expressed
through behaviors such as sitting close to child, attending to the child's
actions, and maintaining focus on the child and task during the entire session.
Structuring Caregiver structures the task for the child so as to facilitate the child's
performance. This includes indicating where materials are that the child
needed, placing objects within reach of the child, handing the next object to
the child, or verbally indicating steps to the process of completing the task.
Communication amount Amount of talk or verbal statements caregiver makes to the child. High scores
represent a caregiver who talks to the child throughout the session. This
category does not consider the form of language caregiver provides, but
rather the sheer amount of talk.
Explanatory language When speaking to the child, the caregiver displays a style of communication
that contains high use of descriptive and explanatory language, as
characterized by high use of labels, adjectives, adverbs, and questions to
child (e.g., “Those are the ingredients for the cake”; “Where do you think the
red piece goes?”; “Which utensil should we use?”).
Directive language When speaking to the child, the caregiver displays a style of communication
that contains high use of imperatives (commands) and high use of pronouns
rather than descriptive language (e.g., “Put that one there”. “Get that one”).
Negative affect Caregiver demonstrates negative affect towards child through facial
expressions (frowns, negative expression), gestures (pushing or pulling
child), and voice tone (anger or harshness).
Negative verbal Caregiver expresses disapproval towards the child verbally, including
criticizing child (“You are making a mess”) and discouraging statements or
discontent (“I don't like what you're doing”).
Intrusiveness Caregiver displays high levels of control and intrusiveness during the
interaction, by prohibiting child's actions, interrupting child's actions, and
taking over the task. Examples include the caregiver hovering over the child,
restricting the child's behaviors, taking objects away from the child,
introducing new objects or actions while the child is engaged in something
else, refusing to hand over objects to the child that are needed so that the
caregiver can complete the project without the child actively participating.
Inflexibility Caregiver is unable to “bend the rules” during interactions, and is inflexible
by not accepting the child's initiatives. Examples include, insisting that the
child engages in a particular activity selected by the mother, even if the child
wishes to do something different, and not switching to a different strategy or
task when the current strategy is not effective with the child.
Child behavior items
Positive affect The child displays positive affect and pleasure when engaging in the task as
expressed through facial expressions (smiles, laughter), tone of voice, body
position, and gestures.
Language amount Amount of talk or verbal statements by child during the session. High scores
represent a child who is talkative throughout the session. This category does
not consider the form of language, but rather the sheer amount of talk.
Communication style Amount of talk or verbal statements child makes. High scores represent a child who is very verbal during the session by commenting on activities, asking for assistance or clarification, and speaking about non-task related
topics.
Initiation Child takes initiative in carrying through with the task, and seeks
information/input/feedback from caregiver that is directed to the task, either
verbally or through gestures. Examples might be a child pointing to the
materials needed, or asking information about how to complete the task
(“How do I crack the egg?”).
Task involvement Child demonstrates interest and engagement with the task materials, both
verbally (by talking about the task) as well as non-verbally (by attending to
the task and manipulating the materials).
Activity level Child displays high activity level during the task, which may be directed
toward the caregiver or task, but might also reflect general arousal and lack a
focus. Examples include child moving around, fidgeting, continually
manipulating the task materials, etc.
Task persistence Child seeks out and explores aspects of the task materials visually and
manually. Child maintains visual attention to the task, remains focused on the
task, and carries through with task activities.
Task competence Child demonstrates competence in the task by successfully completing
various steps to the task (e.g., cracking eggs, combining ingredients).
Responsiveness Child responds to and cooperates with the caregiver during the interaction.
Child is accepting of the caregiver's directions, for example by following
through on what the caregiver suggests or verbally acknowledging the
caregiver's suggestions (“Yeah, I'll do that”).
Participation Child participates with the caregiver during the session, as expressed by
verbal and nonverbal behaviors (e.g., talking to caregiver, looking at what
caregiver is doing). The child initiates interactions with the caregiver (“How
do you do this one?”; “Can you help me?”) as well as follows through with
caregiver initiated actions.
Emotion regulation The child is able to maintain self-regulation both in actions and emotions.
Child remains focused on the task, is not easily distractible, and remains calm rather than upset or angry throughout the session.
Negative affect Child demonstrates negative affect through facial expressions (frowns,
negative expression), gestures, and voice tone (e.g., angry and/or generally
unhappy, sad tones).