Skip to main content
. 2009 Jul 24;106(30):491–498. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2009.0491

Table 2. Arbitration proceedings after the treatment of fractures in children.

Specialty and site of treatment Persons and institutions against whom proceedings were initiated, N1 Complaints made, N2 Therapeutic errors (avoidable errors confirmed by arbitration board), n Therapeutic errors, (n/N2, expressed in percent)
Trauma surgery, including hand surgery
Hospital, inpatient 71 99 55 56
Hospital, outpatient 32 41 26 63
Doctor’s office 21 25 17 68
Total: 124 165 98 59
General/visceral surgery
Hospital, inpatient 14 22 14 64
Hospital, outpatient 15 16 14 88
Doctor’s office 21 27 19 70
Total: 50 65 47 71
Pediatric surgery
Hospital, inpatient 12 16 12 75
Hospital, outpatient 3 5 1 20
Doctor’s office 1 2 1 50
Total: 16 23 14 61
Orthopedics
Doctor’s office 8 11 5 45
Pediatrics
Hospital 4 5 1 20
Doctor’s office 1 2 2 100
Total: 5 7 3 43
General medicine
3 4 4 100
Otorhinolaryngology
Doctor’s office (1 facial & 2 nasal fractures) 3 3 1 33
Obstetrics
Hospital
(2 cases of birth trauma) 2 2 1 50
Anesthesiology
Hospital
(2 incidents involving general anesthesia) 2 2 1 50
Total 213 282 174 62

Note: There were many cases in which more than one allegation was made and/or more than one error was confirmed.