TABLE 3.
Model | Control Model | Tempol Route of Delivery and Duration | n | Tempol Maximum Dose or Dose Used to Compare Groups | ROS Marker and Value in Hypertensive Group without Tempol | Control ROS Value in Normotensive Group | ROS Value in Hypertensive Group with Tempol | Change in ROS | Normalization of ROS | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
% | ||||||||||
Studies in hypertensive rat models | ||||||||||
ACTH [0.2 (mg ·kg)/d s.c.] | Vehicle | p.o. (4 d before to 8 d after ACTH) | 10 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso, 12.9 nM | 8.4 | 4 d pre, 16.3 8 d post, 13.2 |
+26/+28-iso d 4/8 (NS/NS) | −26/−2 | Zhang et al., 2003b |
Aldosterone (0.75 μg/h s.c. + salt 1% for 6 wk) | Vehicle | p.o. for 6 wk | 8 | 3 mM | Renal cortex TBARS, 0.23 nmol/mg protein | 0.10 | 0.11 | −52* | 92 | Nishiyama et al., 2004a |
Urine TBARS, 0.39 μmol/d | 0.10 | 0.13 | −67* | 90 | ||||||
Aldosterone (0.75 μg/h s.c. for 6 wk) | Vehicle | p.o. for 6 wk | 7 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso, 16.8 ng/ml | 13.1 | 10.6 | −37* | 166 | Iglarz et al., 2004 |
NADPH-generated in heart/aorta/kidney/mesenteric artery, 230/930/1500/670 cpm/mg tissue | 122/300/250/150 | 78/340/250/200 | −66*/−63*/−83*/70* | 141/94/100/90 | ||||||
Ang II [5 (ng · kg)/min i.v. for 15 d] | Vehicle | p.o. for 15 d | 6 | 1 mM | Plasma/renal vein 8-iso, 193/353 pg/ml | 122/202 | 122/242 | −37*/−31* | 100/74 | Ortiz et al., 2001a |
Plasma/renal vein TBARS, 1.7/1.9 nmol/ml | 0.8/0.7 | 1.2/1.1 | −33*/−36* | 56/67 | ||||||
Ang II [100 (ng ·kg)/min s.c. ± 8% salt for 12 d] | Vehicle | p.o. for 12 d | 5 | 1 mM | Plasma cholesterol ester hydroperoxide levels, 0.27 μM | 0.13 | 0.13 | −52* | 100 | Ogihara et al., 2002 |
Ang II [200 (ng ·kg)/min s.c. for 2 wk] | Vehicle | s.c. for 2 wk | 8–11 | 200 (nmol ·kg)/min | Kidney cortex NADPH oxidase activity, 3.6 nmol of /(min · mg protein) | 2.3 | 2.7 | −15* | 69 | Welch et al., 2005a |
Ang II [300 (ng ·kg)/min s.c. for 7 d] | Vehicle | p.o. for 7 d | 8 | 2 mM | Aortic , 4.3 RLU | 0.7 | 1.3 | −70* | 83 | Hattori et al., 2005 |
BSO (30 mM for 2 wk) | Vehicle | p.o. for 2 wk | 8 | 1 mM | Urine 8-Iso/Cr, 1.2 pg/mg | 0.80 | 0.82 | −33* | 98 | Banday et al., 2007a |
BSO (30 + HS) | HS | p.o. for 12 d | 8 | 1 mM | Urine 8-Iso/Cr, 1.3 pg/mg | 0.84 | 0.86 | −34* | 96 | Banday et al., 2007c |
Capsaicin-4% salt | 4% salt | p.o. (gavage) for 3 wk | 5–6 | 1 (mmol · kg)/d | Mesenteric artery , 1125 cpm/mg tissue | 730 | 950 | −16* | 44 | Song et al., 2004 |
Cyclosporine [30 (mg · kg)/d s.c.] | Vehicle | p.o. for 3 wk | 7 | 3 mM | Kidney TBARS, 37 nmol/g | 24 | 19 | −49* | 138 | Nishiyama et al., 2003 |
Aortic , 26 cpm | 17 | 16 | −38* | 111 | ||||||
DETC [7.5 (mg · kg)/d into medullary interstitium; SD] | Tempol only, no DETC | Infused into medullary interstitium for 8 d before and during DETC | 8 | 58 (μmol · kg)/d | Urine 8-iso, 8.8 ng/d | 4.1 ng/d | 4.2 ng/d | −52* | 98 | Makino et al., 2003 |
Dexamethasone [10 μg · kg)/d s.c.] | Vehicle | p.o. (4 d before to 8 d after Dex) | 10 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso, 12 nM | 8.8 | 4 d before, 10.4 8 d after, 10 |
−13/17, d 4/8 (NS/NS) | 50/63 | Zhang et al., 2004b |
DOCA + salt 0.9% | Sham | p.o. for 3 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Aortic , 3166 (mU · mg)/min | 875 | 824 | −74* | 102 | Ghosh et al., 2004 |
DOCA + salt | SD/sham high salt | i.p. for 3 wk | 8 | 87 (μmol · kg)/d | Plasma 8-iso, 0.77 ng/ml | 0.20 | 0.36 | −53* | 72 | Adeagbo et al., 2003 |
DOCA + salt 1% | Sham | p.o. for 4 wk | 10 | 1 mM | aortic rings, 7153 cpm/mg tissue | 3055 | 2939 | −59* | 103 | Beswick et al., 2001 |
DOCA + salt 1% | Sham | p.o. for 5 wk | 13 | 1 mM | Aortic , 1250 RLU/(min · mg) | 525 | 750 | −40* | 69 | Nakano et al., 2003 |
DSS + 8% salt | DSR | p.o. for 10 wk | 9 | 3 mM | Plasma TBARS, 14 nmol/ml | 7 | 7 | −50* | 100 | Guo et al., 2006 |
Cardiac NADPH oxidase, 361 cpm/mg protein | 245 | 185 | −49* | 152 | ||||||
DSS + 8% salt | DSS LS | p.o. for 5 wk | 5 | 10 mM | 8-OHdG-positive cells, 347 cells/area | 159 | 259 | −25* | 47 | Hisaki et al., 2005 |
DSS + 8% salt | DSS LS | p.o. for 4 wk | 8 | 3 mM | Urine TBARS, 0.66 μmol/d | 0.14 | 0.24 | −64* | 81 | Kobori and Nishiyama, 2004 |
DSS + 8% salt | DSS LS | p.o. for 2 wk | 9 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 14 ng/d | 7.4 | 8 | −43* | 91 | Hoagland et al., 2003 |
DSS + 8% salt | DSS LS | p.o. for 4 wk | 8 | 3 mM | Kidney TBARS, 86 nmol/g | 41 | 48 | −46* | 88 | Nishiyama et al., 2004b |
DSS + 8% salt + L-NAME | DSS LS | p.o. for 2 wk | 9 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 15.2 ng/d | 7.4 | 7.5 | −51* | 99 | Hoagland et al., 2003 |
DSS + 8% salt + HET- 0016 (20-HETE blocker) | DSS LS | p.o. for 2 wk | 9 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 14.6 ng/d | 7.4 | 8.5 | −42* | 85 | Hoagland et al., 2003 |
DSS + salt | DSS LS | i.v. for 3 wk | 7 | 3 (mmol · kg)/d | Renal cortical/medullary , 72/35 cpm/mg protein | 47/26 | 22/12 | −69*/−66* | 200/256 | Meng et al., 2003 |
ET-1 [5 (pmol · kg)/min i.v. +8% salt] | Vehicle- infused, normal salt | p.o. for 12 d | 7–10 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso, 128 pg/ml | 52 | 72 | −44* | 74 | Elmarakby et al., 2005 |
Aortic , 740 cpm/mg | 90 | 210 | −72* | 82 | ||||||
ET-1 [5 (pmol ·kg)/min i.v. +8% salt] | Untreated | s.c. for 12 d | 7–10 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Aortic , 740 cpm/mg | 90 | 240 | −68* | 77 | Elmarakby et al., 2005 |
ET-1 [5 (pmol ·kg)/min i.v.] | Vehicle- infused | i.v. for 9 d | 6 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Kidney TBARS, 462 ng/μg of protein | 48 | 287 | −38 (N.S.) | 42 (N.S.) | Sedeek et al., 2003 |
Urine 8-iso, 11 ng/d | 7.5 | 8.9 | −19* | 60 | ||||||
ET-B antagonist (A- 192621) p.o. | Vehicle- treated | p.o. for 1 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso, 25 pg/ml | 18 | 23 | −8 (N.S.) | 29 | Williams et al., 2004 |
Urine H2O2, 4 nmol d | −1 | −1 | −75* | 100 | ||||||
ET-B antagonist + 10% salt p.o. | Vehicle- treated | p.o. for 1 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso d 3/7, 75/66 pg/ml | 18 | 57/66 | −24/0 (NS/NS) | 32/0 | Williams et al., 2004 |
ET-B deficient + 8% salt | Wild type; 8% NaCl | p.o. for 15 d | 20 | 1 mM | Urine TBARS, 1164 nmol/24 h | 1314 | 1169 | −11* | 11 | Sullivan et al., 2006 |
High salt 10% | Normal salt | p.o. for 1 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Plasma 8-iso d 3/7, −64/50 pg/ml | 18 | 60/63 | −6/−26 (NS/NS) | 9/26 | Williams et al., 2004 |
Urine H2O2, 3 nmol/d | −1 | 2 | −33* | 50 | ||||||
Hyperthyroid (s.c. T4 for 6 wk) | Vehicle infused | p.o. for 6 wk | 8 | 1 mM | Plasma MDA, 10.2 μM | 6.8 | 7.5 | −26* | 79 | Moreno et al., 2005 |
Urine 8-iso, 12.5 μg/d | 6.5 | 7.5 | −40* | 83 | ||||||
1K,1C | Sham uninephrec- tomized | p.o. for 2 wk 2 d | 6 | 2 mM | Aortic rings/ , 80 (RLU 15 min/mg) | 42 | 63 | −21* | 45 | Dobrian et al., 2001 |
Renal nitrotyrosine, 59 ng/mg of protein | 14 | 32 | −46* | 60 | ||||||
Plasma 8-iso, 240 pg/ml | 305 | 340 | −42* | 0 | ||||||
1K,1C (10 wk) | Sham | p.o. for 5 wk | 5 | 1 mM | DHE fluorescence in mesenteric arteries | 16 | 25 | −38* | 68 | Christensen et al., 2007b |
2K,1C | Sham | s.c. minipump for 13 d | 8 | 288 (μmol ·kg)/d | Urine 8-iso, 12.5 ng/d | 8 | 9 | −28* | 78 | Welch et al., 2003 |
Urine MDA, 610 μmol/d | 400 | 330 | −46* | 133 | ||||||
Leptin | Leptin untreated | p.o. for 7 d | 8 | 2 mM | Urine 8-iso, 325 ng/d | 190 | 225 | −31* | 43 | Beltowski et al., 2005 |
Plasma 8-iso, 218 pg/ml | 130 | 138 | −37* | 91 | ||||||
Obese Zucker | Lean | p.o. for 15 d | 10 | 1 mM | Renal MDA, 0.91 nmol/mg | 0.55 | 0.59 | −35* | 89 | Banday et al., 2005 |
Offspring of protein malnourished mothers | Offspring of normal mothers | p.o. for 13 wk | 14–19 | 2 mM | Kidney nitrotyrosine, 1.42 (relative abundance) | 1.0 | 0.45 | −70* | 100 | Stewart et al., 2005 |
Ren-2 transgenic rat | Control | p.o. for 3 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Cardiac MDA, 0.60 μm/mg of protein | 47 | 0.33 | −45* | 207 | Whaley- Connell et al., 2007 |
Ren-2 transgenic rat | SD | p.o. for 3 wk | 6 | 1 mM | NADPH oxidase of mesenteric arteries, 18 | 11 | 13 | −28* | 71 | Whaley- Connell et al., 2007 |
SD + HS (1% NaCl) + BSO (30 mM for 12 d] | HS | p.o. for 12 d | 8 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 54 pg/mg Cr | 41 | 42 | −22* | 92 | Banday et al., 2007d |
SHR | WKY | s.c. for 2 wk | 6–8 | 200 (nmol ·kg)/min | Urine 8-iso, 13.2 ng/d | N.A. | 9.6 | −27* | N.A. | Welch et al., 2005b |
SHR | Untreated SHR | p.o. for 2 wk | 6–8 | 1 mM | Kidney cortex , 11,889 RLU | N.A. | 9315 | −22* | N.A. | Yanes et al., 2005 |
Medulla, 6413 RLU | 5944 (N.S.) | −7 (N.S.) | ||||||||
Plasma total anti- oxidant, 1.2 nM | 1.57 | −31* | ||||||||
Urine 8-iso, 2.21 ng/mg of creatinine | 1.53 | −31* | ||||||||
SHR | WKY | p.o. for 15 wk | 6–12 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Kidney 8-iso, 5.2 ng/mg of tissue | 1.7 | 1.7 | −67* | 100 | Fortepiani and Reckelhoff, 2005 |
SHR | WKY | p.o. for 6 wk | 6–12 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Kidney 8-iso, 5.3 ng/mg of tissue | 1.7 | 4.8 | −9* | 14 | Fortepiani and Reckelhoff, 2005 |
SHR | WKY | p.o. for 2 wk | 8 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 9.8 ng/d | 6.8 | 6.0 | −39* | 127 | Schnackenberg and Wilcox, 1999 |
SHR aging (16 mo) | Untreated SHR | p.o. for 8 mo | 6 | 6 mM | Urine 8-iso, 20 ng/d | N.A. | 12 | −40* | NA | Fortepiani et al., 2003 |
SHR aging female (16 mo) | Untreated SHR female | p.o. for 8 mo | 6 | 6 mM | Urine 8-iso, 45 ng/d | N.A. | 37 | −18* | N.A. | Fortepiani et al., 2003 |
SHR aging (16 mo) | Untreated SHR | p.o. for 8 mo | 10 | 1 mM | Urine 8-iso, 1.84 (ng ·mg Cr)/d | N.A. | 1.28 | −30* | N.A. | Payne et al., 2003 |
SHR female | WKY | p.o. for 15 wk | 6–12 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Kidney 8-iso, 3.7 ng/mg of tissue | 2.2 | 1.7 | −54* | 133 | Fortepiani and Reckelhoff, 2005 |
SHR female | WKY | p.o. for 6 wk | 6–12 | 170 (μmol ·kg)/d | Kidney 8-iso, 3.6 ng/mg of tissue | 2.2 | 3.7 | −3 (N.S.) | 0 | Fortepiani and Reckelhoff, 2005 |
SHR + L-NAME | Untreated SHR | p.o. for 2 wk | 6–8 | 1 mM | Kidney cortex , 10,423 RLU | N.A. | 9506 | −9* | N.A. | Yanes et al., 2005 |
Medulla, 7422 RLU | 5248 | −29* | ||||||||
Plasma total antioxidant, 1.25 nM | 1.46 | −17* | ||||||||
Urine 8-iso, 1.89 ng/mg creatinine | 1.32 | −30* | ||||||||
SHRsp low Mg2+diet | Untreated SHRsp | p.o. for 7 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Plasma TBARS, 2.7 μmol/ml | N.A. | 1.5 | −44* | N.A. | Touyz et al., 2002 |
Vascular , 1.2 (nmol ·min)/mg tissue | 0.6 | −50* | ||||||||
SHRsp 4% salt | Untreated SHRsp | p.o. for 6 wk | 6 | 1 mM | Vascular , 19 RLU | N.A. | 4 | −79* | N.A. | Park et al., 2002 |
Plasma total antioxidants, 0.85 nM | 1.1 | −29* | ||||||||
Streptozotocin (DM)/L-NAME | SD, tempol untreated | i.v. for 2 wk | 5 | 18 (μmol ·kg)/h | Urine 8-iso, 118 ng/d | 23 | 40 | −66* | 82 | Brands et al., |
Studies in hypertensive mouse models | ||||||||||
Ang II [0.7 (mg ·kg)/d], WT mice | Vehicle | s.c. for 2 wk | 28 (mmol ·kg)/d | Aortic , 125 pmol/mg of tissue | 50 | 85 | −32* | 53 | Dikalova et al., 2005 | |
Ang II infused [0.7 (mg · kg)/d] Nox-1- overexpressing mice | Vehicle | s.c. for 2 wk | 28 (mmol ·kg)/d | Aortic , 250 pmol/mg of tissue | 75 | 160 | −36* | 51 | Dikalova et al., 2005 |
Mean values are shown.
8-iso, 8-isoprostane PGF2α; TBARS, thiobarbituric acid reactive agent; RLU, relative light unit; HS, high salt; Dex, dexamethasone; DSR, Dahl salt-resistant rat; LS, low salt; 8OHdG, 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine; HET-0016, N-hydroxy-N′-(4-butyl-2-methylphenyl)-formamidine; N.A., not applicable; adrenocorticotropin; d, day(s); wk, week(s); mo, month(s).
Significant change with tempol.