TABLE 2.
Comparison of Annual Incidence and Prevalence of Youths' Suicide Attempt Rates Across Similar Studies
| Incidence or Prevalence of Having Made a Suicide Attempt in Past 12 Mo | Definition of Youths | Sample Type | Methods | Sample Size | Gender Ratios | Year(s) of Data Collection | |
| White Mountain Apache Surveillance Registry, 2008 | Annual incidence rate of 3495 per 100 000 (approximately 3.5%) | 15–24 y | Mandatory tribal surveillance system among White Mountain Apache Tribe | Surveillance | ∼15 500 | Males and females equally likely to have made attempt reported to registry | 2001–2006 |
| Langlois and Morrison, 200213 | Annual incidence rate of 152 per 100 000 hospitalizations for attempted suicide (approximately 0.2%) | 15–19 y | 1999 Canadian Hospital Morbidity Database | Nationally maintained inpatient database | NA | Females 2.5 times more likely to have been hospitalized for attempt than were males | 1998–1999 |
| Andrus et al., 199114 | Annual incidence rate of 214 per 100 000 (approximately 0.2%) | 10–17 y | Mandatory statewide hospital surveillance system in Oregon | Surveillance | 70 hospitals | Majority (83%) of those who attempted were female | 1988 |
| Eaton et al., 200615 | 8.4% reported having attempted suicide; 2.3% reported having made attempt that required medical treatment | 9th–12th graders | 2005 nationally representative Youth Risk Behavior Survey among public and private high school students | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 13 917 | Females 1.8 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 2004–2005 |
| Lemaster et al., 200416 | 1.4% reported having attempted suicide | 15–24 y | Population-based survey among Northern Plains American Indians | Face-to-face interviews | 1 638 | Similar rates reported between males and females | 1997–1999 |
| Shaughnessy et al., 200417 | 16.0% reported having attempted suicide | 9th–12th graders | 2001 Youth Risk Behavior Survey among Bureau of Indian Affairs–funded schools in 22 states | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 5 624 | Females 1.6 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 2001 |
| Benally et al., 200318 | 20.0% reported having attempted suicide | 9th–12th graders | 2003 Navajo Youth Risk Behavior Survey among high schools on or near Navajo Nation with at least 50% Navajo student enrollment | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 8 374 | Females 1.7 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 2003 |
| Borowsky et al., 200119 | 3.6% reported having attempted suicide | 7th–12th graders | 1995–1996 National Longitudinal Survey of Adolescent Health | In-school survey, in-home interviews | 13 110 | Females 2.5 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 1994–1996 |
| Borowsky et al., 199920 | 9.1% reported having attempted suicide | 7th–12th graders | 1990 National American Indian Adolescent Health Survey among schools of reservation communities | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 11 666 | Females 1.8 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 1990 |
| Garrison et al., 199321 | 5.9% reported having made attempt that did not require medical care; 1.6% reported having made attempt that required medical treatment | 9th–12th graders | 1990 South Carolina Youth Risk Behavior Survey among public high school students | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 3 764 | Females 2 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 1990 |
| Meehan et al., 199222 | 1.9% reported having attempted suicide; 0.4% reported having sought medical care as a result of suicide attempt | 18–24 y | Freshman students at major public university in Nevada | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 694 | NA | Unclear (approximately 1990) |
| Grossman et al., 199123 | 9.5% reported having attempted suicide | 6th–12th graders | 1988 Indian Health Service Adolescent Health Survey among students on Navajo reservation | Anonymous self-administered questionnaire | 7 254 | Females 1.8 times more likely to report attempt than were males | 1988 |
Note. NA = not available.