Table 2.
First author (year) | Experimental group | Control group |
---|---|---|
Park (2007) (9) | (1) Soyangin: KI17(T), LR2(S), TE6(S) | LR3, GB34, ST36 |
(2) Taeyangin: LR8(T), HT7(S), SP3(S) | ||
(3) Soeumin: SP2(T), LU5(S), KI10(S) | ||
(4) Taeeumin: LU9(T), KI1(S), LR1(S) | ||
Chae (2001) (10) | Basic prescription (5 times) | Bilateral: BL23, BL24, BL25, BL26 |
(1) Metal-Yang: LU8(S), LR4 (S), KI10(T), LR8(T) | Some of bilateral: BL31–34, | |
(2) Metal-Yin: KI10(S), LU5(S), LR1(T), LU11(T) | Pain side of GB30, BL40, BL57, BL60 | |
(3) Earth-Yang: SP3(S), KI3(S), LU8(T), KI7(T) | ||
(4) Earth-Yin: LU8(S), SP5(S), KI10(T), SP9(T) | ||
(5) Wood-Yang: LR8(S), KI10(S), LU8(T), LR4(T) | ||
(6) Wood-Yin: KI10(T), LU5(T), LR1(S), LU11(S) | ||
(7) Water-Yang: SP3(T), KI3(T), LU8(S), KI7(S) | ||
(8) Water-Yin: LU8(T), SP5(T), KI10(S), SP9(S) | ||
Supplemented prescription-Organ System Inflammation (5 times) | ||
(1) Metal-Yang: SP3(S), LU9(S), LR1(T), LU11(T) | ||
(2) Metal-Yin: LR4(S), LU8(S), HT8(T), LR2(T) | ||
(3) Earth-Yang: HT8(S), SP2(S), KI10(T), SP9(T) | ||
(4) Earth-Yin: SP3(S), KI3(S), LR1(T), KI1(T) | ||
(5) Wood-Yang: SP3(T), LU9(T), LR1(S), LU11(S) | ||
(6) Wood-Yin: LR4(T), LU8(T), HT8(S), LR2(S) | ||
(7) Water-Yang: HT8(T), SP2(T), KI10(S), SP9(S) | ||
(8) Water-Yin: SP3(T), KI3(T), LR1(S), KI1(S) | ||
Supplemented prescription-Spirit (1 time) | ||
(1) Metal-Yang: PC7(S), PC3(T) | ||
(2) Metal-Yin: SI1(S), SI3(T) | ||
(3) Earth-Yang: HT7(S), HT3(T) | ||
(4) Earth-Yin: TE1(S), TE3(T) | ||
(5) Wood-Yang: PC7(T), PC3(S) | ||
(6) Wood-Yin: SI1(T), SI3(S) | ||
(7) Water-Yang: HT7(T), HT3(S) | ||
(8) Water-Yin: TE1(T), TE3(S) | ||
Chae (2004) (11) | Basic prescription (5 times) | Heding (Extra), Xiyan (internal & external, Extra), |
Same as Chae (10) | SP9, GB34, LR3, SP10, ST34, ST36 | |
Supplemented prescription-Vitality (5 times) | ||
(1) Metal-Yang: ST36(S), LI11(S), GB41(T), LI3(T) | ||
(2) Metal-Yin: LI1(S), GB44(S), SI5(T), GB38(T) | ||
(3) Earth-Yang: SI5(S), ST41(S), BL66(T), ST44(T) | ||
(4) Earth-Yin: ST36(S), BL40(S), GB41(T), BL65(T) | ||
(5) Wood-Yang: ST36(T), LI11(T), GB41(S), LI3(S) | ||
(6) Wood-Yin: LI1(T), GB44(T), SI5(S), GB38(S) | ||
(7) Water-Yang: SI5(T), ST41(T), BL66(S), ST44(S) | ||
(8) Water-Yin: ST36(T), BL40(T), GB41(S), BL65(S) | ||
Supplemented prescription-Spirit (1 times) | ||
Same as Chae (10) |
S: Sedation, T: Tonification.