Skip to main content
. 2009 Sep 18;339:b3435. doi: 10.1136/bmj.b3435

Table 2.

 Division of 40 journals into development and validation sets

Rank* Journal Total contributed articles (n=4657) Articles with renal information (%)
Development set
1 Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation 168 94.6
2 Transplantation Proceedings 171 59.7
3 Journal of the American Society of Nephrology 102 87.3
4 American Journal of Kidney Diseases 85 90.6
5 Pediatric Nephrology 83 67.5
6 American Journal of Transplantation 96 44.8
7 New England Journal of Medicine 376 3.7
8 Diabetes Care 184 5.4
9 American Journal of Medicine 107 7.5
10 Journal of Hypertension 89 9
11 Radiology 136 5.1
12 Journal of Vascular Surgery 73 6.8
13 Lancet 386 0.8
14 Archives of Disease in Childhood 87 3.4
15 Journal of Trauma-Injury Infection & Critical Care 120 1.7
16 Diabetic Medicine 60 1.7
17 Surgical Endoscopy 101 1
18 Journal of the Association of Physicians of India 50 2
19 Calcified Tissue International 22 4.5
20 Journal of Human Genetics 41 2.4
21 Journal of Infection 39 0
22 Journal of Viral Hepatitis 29 0
23 American Journal of Clinical Oncology 22 0
24 Netherlands Journal of Medicine 22 0
Total 2649 22.3
Validation set
1 Kidney International 187 79.7
2 Transplantation 168 37.5
3 Peritoneal Dialysis International 49 100
4 Clinical Transplantation 46 50
5 Journal of Urology 219 10.1
6 Annals of Internal Medicine 130 6.9
7 BMJ 477 1.3
8 Annals of Thoracic Surgery 289 1.7
9 Investigative Radiology 48 6.3
10 Journal of Pediatrics 96 2.1
11 Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 30 3.3
12 American Journal of Clinical Pathology 58 1.7
13 Bone Marrow Transplantation 101 0
14 Family Practice 57 0
15 East African Medical Journal 31 0
16 Diabetes/Metabolism Research Reviews 22 0
Total 2008 16.6

*Ranked by number of articles with renal information.