Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Jun 4.
Published in final edited form as: J Phys Chem B. 2009 Jun 4;113(22):7950–7964. doi: 10.1021/jp900308y

TABLE 2.

Results in kcal/mol for energy and free energy components and their difference (Δ) between the free and bound microstates for Rtmpl=12 and Rwater=13Å#

Eloop-temp Eloop -loop
FwaterTI(ch)
FwaterTI(LJ)
Eloop
FwaterTI
Fsum Etotal
Nwater= 80 ρwater= 0.0170 ns=40
Free −52 −46 −67 27 −98 −40 −138 −1207
Bound −128 −10 −48 17 −138 −31 −169 −1246
Δ1 76 (1) −36 (1) −19 (1) 10 (1) 40 (1) −9 (1) 31(1) 39 (1)
Nwater =100 ρwater= 0.0217 ns=40
Free −50 −45 −71 37 −95 −34 −129 −1389
Bound −128 −10 −48 27 −138 −21 −159 −1435
Δ1 78 (1) −35 (1) −23 (1) 10 (1) 43 (1) −13 (1) 30 (1) 46 (3)
Nwater =120 ρwater= 0.0261 ns=40
Free −102 −25 −63 57 −127 −6 −133 −1646
Bound −128 −10 −50 41 −138 −9 −147 −1653
Δ2 26 (1) −15 (1) −13 (2) 16 (1) 11 (2) 3 (3) 14 (2) 7 (1)
Nwater =140 ρwater= 0.0304 ns=80
Free −75 −34 −76 99 −109 23 −86 −1788
Bound −118 −5 −50 95 −123 45 −78 −1791
Δ3 43 (1) −29 (1) −26 (1) 4 (1) 14 (1) −22 (1) −8 (2) 3 (3)
Nwater =160 ρwater= 0.0348 ns=80 double integration
Free −77 −10 −81 123 −87 42 −45 −1981
Bound −121 −1 −53 131 −122 78 −44 −1962
Δ3 44 (1) −9 (2) −28 (1) −8 (1) 35 (1) −36 (2) −1 (2) −19 (5)
Nwater =180 ρwater= 0.0391 ns=80 double integration
Free −71 −37 −84 148 −108 64 −44 −2155
Bound −119 1 −48 127 −118 79 −39 −2160
Δ3 48 (1) −38 (1) −36 (1) 21 (4) 10 (1) −15 (4) −5 (4) 5 (2)
#

The energies, Eloop-tmpl, Eloop-loop , their sum, Eloop, and the total energy, Etotal are defined in eq 1.FwaterTI(ch)andFwaterTI(LJ) are free energies calculated by thermodynamic integration, where the charges and Lennard-Jones interactions, respectively, are gradually eliminated; they and their sum, FwaterTI are defined in eq 21. Fsum=Eloop+FwaterTI is the total free energy (without the contribution of the loop entropy, Sloop). Δ is the difference, free – bound. Nwater is the number of capped water molecules. Pwater=Nwater/[2π(Rwater)3/3] is the density of water (in Å−3 units) in the hemisphere defined by the radius, Rwater. ns is the sample size. Statistical errors, s/(ns)1/2, where s is the standard deviation, are smaller than 2.5 and 1.5 kcal/mol for Etotal and the other quantities, respectively. The errors in Δ appear in parenthesis, e.g., −46 (2) =−46±2; thus, the 2 kcal/mol in this example is the difference between the value which appears in the table and the value obtained for a smaller sample size, ns: 1for ns=20; 2for ns=17; 3for ns=40. Double integration means that the MD simulation at each TI step is doubled - it is 40 ps for each λi step.