TABLE 2.
Study authors (reference) | Surface area | Sample concn | Surface seeding | Sampling method | Extraction method | Extraction vol | Total vol | Recovery efficiency (%) | Extraction efficiency (%) | Culture medium | Limit of detection |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hodges et al. (38) | 10 cm2 | 0.2-3,000 CFU/cm2 | Inoculated with 0.5 ml spore solution | Macrofoam swab | Vortex in 5 ml PBST for 2 min at 10-s intervals | 5 ml | 31.7-49.1 | 93.4 | Sheep blood agar | 12 CFU/cm2 | |
Rose et al. (59) | 25 cm2 | 2 × 104 CFU/cm2 | Inoculated with 0.5 ml spore solution | Cotton swab, macrofoam swab | Vortex in 5 ml PBST for 2 min at 10-s intervals | 5 ml | 100 μl | 41.7 for cotton swab, 43.6 for macrofoam swab | 93.9 for cotton swab, 93.4 for macrofoam swab | Trypticase soy agar with 5% sheep blood | 20 CFU/cm2a |
Brown et al. (15) | 25 cm2 | 100-10,000 CFU/cm2 | Dry aerosol deposition | Polyester-rayon blend gauze wipe | Sonication and heat treatment | 30 ml | 1 ml | 35 for stainless steel, 29 for painted wallboard | 93 | Brain heart infusion agar | 90 CFU/cm2 for stainless steel, 105 CFU/cm2 for painted wallboard |
Brown et al. (16) | 25 cm2 | 100-10,000 CFU/cm2 | Dry aerosol deposition | Rayon swab | Sonication and heat treatment | 10 ml | 1 ml | 41 for stainless steel, 41 for painted wallboard | 76 | Brain heart infusion agar | 1 CFU/cm2 for stainless steel and painted wallboard |
Brown et al. (14) | 100 cm2 | 100-10,000 CFU/cm2 | Dry aerosol deposition | Vacuum filter sock | Sonication and heat treatment | 30 ml | 1 ml | 29 for stainless steel, 25 for painted wallboard, 28 for carpet, 19 for concrete | Petrifilm aerobic count plate | 105 CFU/m2 for stainless steel and carpet, 102 CFU/m2 for painted wallboard, 160 CFU/m2 for concrete | |
Buttner et al. (20) | 1 m2 | 105 CFU/m2 | Inoculated with spore solution | BiSKit—wet/dry | Foam compression | 3.3 ml for wet sampling, 16.1 ml for dry sampling | 1 ml | 11.3 for wet sampling, 18.4 for dry sampling | Trypticase soy agar | 42 ± 6 CFU/m2 for wet sampling, 100 ± 10 CFU/m2 for dry sampling |
The limit of detection was not recorded in the article and was calculated to be at least 20 CFU/cm2.