Table 2. Comparison of the characteristics of oxygen cylinders and oxygen concentratorsa.
| Characteristics | Cylinders | Concentrators | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital cost | High when regulator and flowmeter costs included | High | ||
| Running cost | High, particularly if leakage is significant | Low if power is inexpensive | ||
| High if power is expensive | ||||
| Ease of use | Some training required | Considerable training required | ||
| Reliability | Good | Good on selected models | ||
| Physical robustness | Good | Fair | ||
| Regular maintenance | Needed | Needed | ||
| Technical repairs | Needed (e.g. for regulators, to minimize leakage) | Needed (maintenance staff require specialized training) | ||
| Electricity | Not needed | Needed | ||
| Continuity of oxygen delivery | Liable to run out | Good as long as power is available | ||
| Portability | Poor for large cylinders | Good | ||
| Supply system | Transport needed Ordering needed | Transport not needed | ||
| Ordering not needed |
a Table adapted from the WHO Acute Respiratory Infections Programme oxygen handbook.19