Table 4.
Study | Sample | Age | Method | Clinical Status at Testing | Medication Status | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(Drevets et al., 1997a) | 10 MDD 21 HC |
39±7.3 34±8.2 |
1mm ROI |
Depressed | Unmedicated 4+ weeks | Decreased volume of L sgACC in MDD group |
(Botteron et al., 2002) | 30 MDD 8HC |
20.2±1.6 | 1mm ROI |
Depressed | Less than 10% of MDD sample on medication. | Decreased volume of L sgACC in MDD |
(Kegeles et al., 2003) | 19 (14 MDD, 5 BD) 10 HC |
36±11 39±19 |
1.5mm ROI |
Depressed | BZ discontinued 24 hours before study in 12 cases. 7 subjects on BZ. Patients free of other medication for 2+ weeks. | NS |
(Hastings et al., 2004) | 18 MDD 18 HC |
38.9±11.4 34.8±13.6 |
1.5mm ROI |
Depressed | Unmedicated | Volume reduction in L sgACC in males only |
(Coryell et al., 2005) | 10 MDD 10 SCZ 10 HC |
22±4.9 22±6.0 |
1mm ROI |
Depressed | NR | Volume reductions in L posterior sgACC but not anterior sgACC in MDD with psychotic features |
(Boes et al., 2008) | 31 HC – no family history 28 HC - + family history |
12.0±2.72 12.1±2.13 |
1.5mm ROI |
Mixed | NR | In boys (but not girls) with subclinical depression smaller L perigenual (sgACC + pgACC) volumes. |
(Chen et al., 2007a) | 17 MDD | 44.1±8.36 | 3mm VBM |
Depressed | Scanned before and after treatment with fluoxetine. Patients unmedicated 4+ weeks before study. | Greater GM volume of pgACC (0, 41, 2) and sgACC (0, −31, −2) associated with faster improvement to fluoxetine |
(Tang et al., 2007) | 14 MDD 13 HC |
29.5±6.84 29.5±6.86 |
1.6mm ROI |
Depressed | Naive | Decreased volume of sgACC in MDD at x=2; y=30; z= −2 |
(Yucel et al., 2008) | 65 MDD 93 HC |
28.8±10.3 28.4±10.7 |
1.2mm ROI |
Depressed | Short-term treatment with various AD | Decreased volume of BA25 in MDD Only MDD patients with medication exposure had smaller BA24 volume. |
Note: AD=antidepressant medication; BZ=benzodiazepenes; HC=healthy control; MDD=major depressive disorder; NR=not reported; NS=not significant; pgACC=perigenual anterior cingulated cortex; sgACC=subgenual anterior cingulated cortex; ROI=region of interest; VBM=voxel-based morphometry.