Skip to main content
. 2009 Oct;126(4):2002–2010. doi: 10.1121/1.3183592

Table 2.

Modal analysis comparisons for three different methods. Rightmost column indicates the maximum percent difference between COMSOL predictions and the remaining two methods.

Mode Mode shapea Modal frequency (Hz) Maximum difference
Experimental ABAQUS COMSOL
1 z-10 75 74.17 74.52 −6.9%
2 z-20 106.55 107.08 0.50%
3 y-10 125.57 125.67 0.08%
4 x-10 133.99 134.63 0.48%
5 x-11 150.38 150.91 0.35%
6 x-20 151.32 152.08 0.50%
a

Mode shape convention: Berry et al. (1994).