Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Sep 30.
Published in final edited form as: J Am Chem Soc. 2009 Sep 30;131(38):13709–13721. doi: 10.1021/ja9039373

Table 2.

Leave-one-out correlation and cross-validation of the 31 compounds between the experimental Ki values and binding affinity calculations from the MM-GBSA method (ΔG) and MM-GBSA + ligand reorganization free energy (ΔG+δΔGre).

Compound # RT ln(Ki) ΔG Leave one out
r2
prediction Error ΔG+δΔGre Leave one out
r2
prediction Error
1 −8.92 −21.36 0.36 −9.56 −0.64 −9.40 0.65 −18.39 −0.48
2 −7.30 −18.12 0.35 −6.91 0.39 −6.65 0.64 −16.20 0.65
3 −6.65 −17.86 0.34 −6.74 −0.09 −5.17 0.63 −15.43 1.48
4 −7.66 −16.73 0.34 −5.64 2.02 −6.48 0.65 −16.73 1.18
5 −7.31 −16.31 0.34 −5.26 2.05 −6.31 0.64 −16.24 1.00
6 −8.04 −21.43 0.37 −9.63 −1.59 −9.96 0.68 −17.06 −1.92
7 −9.08 −21.14 0.36 −9.37 −0.29 −9.76 0.66 −18.61 −0.68
8 −9.20 −19.54 0.36 −8.04 1.16 −8.37 0.66 −18.85 0.83
9 −7.24 −13.03 0.34 −1.91 5.33 −6.32 0.64 −16.14 0.92
10 −9.31 −18.58 0.37 −7.26 2.05 −8.19 0.66 −19.02 1.12
11 −10.40 −18.48 0.40 −7.23 3.17 −10.71 0.64 −20.47 −0.31
12 −10.30 −23.41 0.35 −11.25 −0.95 −11.80 0.65 −20.24 −1.50
13 −8.08 −16.40 0.35 −5.36 2.72 −7.23 0.65 −17.28 0.85
14 −5.69 −15.15 0.30 −4.21 1.48 −5.11 0.60 −14.01 0.58
15 −9.68 −20.90 0.36 −9.15 0.53 −10.71 0.65 −19.43 −1.03
16 −7.34 −20.84 0.38 −9.17 −1.83 −9.50 0.70 −15.98 −2.16
17 −5.82 −19.83 0.40 −8.47 −2.65 −7.83 0.69 −13.53 −2.01
18 −8.81 −21.08 0.36 −9.33 −0.52 −7.51 0.66 −18.32 1.30
19 −9.31 −22.47 0.36 −10.47 −1.16 −9.56 0.65 −18.95 −0.25
20 −10.35 −22.71 0.35 −10.64 −0.29 −11.66 0.64 −20.32 −1.31
21 −10.50 −18.32 0.41 −7.12 3.38 −8.84 0.68 −20.80 1.66
22 −11.47 −22.62 0.36 −10.46 1.01 −9.32 0.70 −22.41 2.15
23 −9.79 −25.28 0.36 −12.93 −3.14 −10.09 0.65 −19.62 −0.30
24 −9.11 −21.54 0.36 −9.70 −0.59 −8.66 0.66 −18.70 0.45
25 −10.72 −21.36 0.37 −9.48 1.24 −9.70 0.66 −21.06 1.02
26 −11.28 −22.11 0.36 −10.05 1.23 −12.35 0.62 −21.58 −1.07
27 −11.02 −25.71 0.32 −13.39 −2.37 −13.02 0.63 −21.12 −2.00
28 −10.26 −27.10 0.35 −14.72 −4.46 −9.89 0.65 −20.33 0.37
29 −8.41 −25.10 0.41 −12.56 −4.15 −8.08 0.65 −17.71 0.33
30 −9.20 −22.49 0.36 −10.49 −1.29 −9.45 0.65 −18.80 −0.25
31 −8.51 −21.66 0.37 −9.81 −1.30 −9.16 0.66 −17.81 −0.65

Mean ± SD 0.36 ± 0.02 0.65 ± 0.02
Average unsigned error(kcal/mol) 1.78 1.03