Peer mediated interventions |
Effective High social validity Effective across subclasses intraverbals Generalization data reported |
Loose operational definitions Weak data collection procedures Use of contrived reinforcement contingencies |
Transfer of stimulus control |
Effective Untrained responses emerged Good operational definitions and measurement systems Limited to categorical intraverbals |
Target behaviors not always intraverbals Generalization outside of sessions Use of contrived reinforcement contingencies |
Video modeling |
Focus on conversational intraverbals |
Little generalization to novel stimuli |
Conversation skills training |
Effective |
Required extended participant attending Little generalization or maintenance data Responses under the control of non-verbal stimuli rather than verbal stimuli in some studies Procedures not described in detail |
Discrete trial training (DTT) |
Effective |
Generally reported concerns with DTT procedures (e.g., rote responses, generalization, etc.) |
Direct Instruction Instruction (DI) |
Effective for academic intraverbal repetoires Teaches more in less time Fills in gaps Maximizes time spent on instruction |
Not commonly employed to teach non-academic intraverbal repertoires Programmed and scripted lessons No demonstrated effectiveness with individuals without some intraverbal repertoires |
Precision Teaching (PT) |
Effective in establishing intraverbal repertoires regardless of the form of the stimuli controlling the response Employed with a variety of instructional strategies Employed across a variety of populations and age ranges Investigations specific to retention, endurance, application, and stability |
Data not well documented and published Not descriptive in specific PT components used in interventions Focus on academic intraverbals |