Skip to main content
. 1999 Mar 13;318(7185):702–703. doi: 10.1136/bmj.318.7185.702

Table.

Trainee experience and consultant supervision for all elective and emergency resections

Grade of surgeon No (%) of operations
No (%) of operations undertaken by trainees who were supervised by consultant
Lothian and Borders Trent and Wales Wessex Lothian and Borders Trent and Wales Wessex
Elective:
 Consultant 692 (63.4) 1399 (58.7) 2308 (60.6)  0  0  0
 Senior registrar 225 (20.6) 324 (13.6) 584 (15.3) 72 (32) 65 (20) 47 (8)
 Registrar 161 (17.7) 544 (22.8) 683 (17.9) 85 (53) 150 (28) 153 (22)
 Senior house officer 14 (1.3) 115 (4.8) 122 (3.2)  9 (64) 54 (47)  32 (26)
 Other 0 0 111 (2.9)  0  0  6 (5)
 Total* 1092 (100) 2382 (100) 3808 (100)  166 (15.2) 269 (11.3)   232 (6.1)
Emergency:
 Consultant 188 (38.9) 154 (30.9) 133 (21.7)  0  0  0
 Senior registrar 159 (32.9)  99 (19.9) 162 (26.5) 19 (12) 5 (5)  4 (2)
 Registrar 127 (26.3) 223 (44.7) 250 (40.9) 32 (25) 26 (12) 17 (7)
 Senior house officer  9 (1.9) 23 (4.6) 37 (6.0)  2 (22)  4 (17)  3 (8)
 Other 0 0 30 (4.9)  0  0  0
 Total  483 (100)  499 (100)  612 (100)   53 (11.0) 35 (7.0)   24 (3.9)
*

Does not include 89 cases in which the operating surgeon was unknown (4 in Lothian and Borders, 85 in Wessex). 

Does not include the six supervised operations undertaken by non-training grade surgeons. 

Does not include 7 cases in which the operating surgeon was unknown.