Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2010 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: Addiction. 2009 May 29;104(8):1393–1402. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2009.02603.x

Table 2.

Sequential models of DSM-IV criteria for males and females among new tobacco users by Wave 5 (N=350)

Male
(N=150)
Female
(N=200)
Models df χLR2 χLR2



Model 0 (independence model) 60 194.73 234.98
Models 1- Tolerance or impaired control before withdrawal
1A. Tolerance or impaired control before withdrawal 16 19.05 12.30
1B. Tolerance before withdrawal 25 26.62 22.50
1C. Impaired control before withdrawal 25 30.85 19.82
1D. Tolerance and impaired control before withdrawal 34 38.19 30.85
Models 2- Tolerance or impaired control before attempts to quit
2A. Tolerance or impaired control before attempts to quit 16 5.99 10.40
2B. Tolerance before attempts to quit 25 14.36 28.04
2C. Impaired control before attempts to quit 25 11.02 14.82
2D. Tolerance and impaired control before attempts to quit 34 18.52 31.27
Models 3- Combined best fitting models of Models 1 and 2
3A. (1D+2D) Tolerance and impaired control before
  withdrawal and attempts to quit
47 48.19 55.49
3B. (1D+2C) Tolerance and impaired control before
  withdrawal, impaired control before attempts to quit
44 37.45
Models 4- Modifications of Model 2D for males and Model 3B for
females in the order between withdrawal and attempts to quit
4A. Model 2D+ withdrawal before attempts to quit 38 22.54
4B. Model 2D+ attempts to quit before withdrawal 51 50.23
4C. Model 3B+ attempts to quit before withdrawal 48 43.25
Models 5- Modifications of Model 4A for males in the order between
withdrawal and impaired control
5A. Model 4A+ withdrawal before impaired control 48 33.94
5B. Model 4A+ impaired control before withdrawal 48 46.85
Models 6- Modifications of Model 5A for males and Model 4C for
females in the order between tolerance and impaired control
6A. Model 5A+ tolerance before impaired control 51 40.11
6B. Model 5A+ impaired control before tolerance 55 64.00
6C. Model 4C+ impaired control before tolerance 52 62.12
Models 7- Modifications of Model 6A for males in the order between
tolerance and withdrawal
7A. Model 6A+ tolerance before withdrawal 55 49.22
7B. Model 6A+ withdrawal before tolerance 55 63.57