Skip to main content
. 1999 Jun 5;318(7197):1511–1514. doi: 10.1136/bmj.318.7197.1511

Table.

Details of included studies of treatment of toxoplasmosis in pregnant women

Study Trimester Inclusion criteria Selection of controls Quality score Regimen No of infected children No not infected No lost to follow up % Infected children (95% CI)
Desmonts and Couvreur21 All Seroconversion; significant increase in IgG; clinical signs and high levels of IgG Unknown; historical controls (seroconversion diagnosed retrospectively, after delivery) 3 Spiramycin (2-3 g/day) for at least 1 month: 388  88 297 3 22 (18 to 27)
No treatment: 154  85  60 9 52 (44 to 60)
Douche et al18 All Seroconversion Late seroconversions Inadequate follow up 4 Spiramycin (2g/day): 64 spiramycin + pyrimethamine + sulphadiazine after positive fetal diagnosis: 5   9  60 0 13 (6 to 24)
No treatment: 29  29   0 0 100 (63 to 100)
Excler et al20 First Seroconversion; increase in IgG Unknown 2 Spiramycin (3 g/day): 31   2  29 0 6 (1 to 23)
No treatment: 4   0   4 0 0 (0 to 60)
Second Spiramycin: 55  15  40 0 27 (16 to 41)
No treatment: 13   5   8 0 38 (15 to 68)
Third Spiramycin: 18   5  13 0 28 (11 to 54)
No treatment: 13   9   4 0 69 (39 to 90)
All Spiramycin: 104  22  82 0 21 (14 to 30)
No treatment: 30  14  16 0 47 (29 to 65)
Knerer et al19 14-29 week Seroconversion Untreated patients or non-compliers 4 Spiramycin (3 g/day): 9  0  9 0 0 (0 to 37)
No treatment: 2  2  0 0 100 (20 to 100)
Kräubig et al25 All Seroconversion (18); increase (x2) dye test; dye test >1000 Unknown 4 Pyrimethamine+sulphonamide: 59   3  56 0 5 (1 to 15)
No treatment: 84  14  70 0 17 (10 to 27)
Lambotte et al23 All Seroconversion Untreated patients or non-compliers 4 Spiramycin + sulphadiazine (3 g/day each to 4 weeks/6): 28 No treatment: 101   0  28 0 0 (0 to 15)
 10  91 0 10 (5 to 18)
Roux et al22 All Seroconversion (10); evolutive infection* (18); high IgG titres (25) Late seroconversions (5) Inadequate follow up (1) 3 Spiramycin (3 g/day): 47   2  43 2 4 (0.7 to 15)
No treatment: 6   5   1 0 83 (36 to 99)
Thoumsin et al24 All Seroconversion Unknown 2 Spiramycin + pyrimethamine + suphadiazine (dose unknown): 99  10  89 0 10 (5 to 8)
No treatment: 101  10  91 0 10 (5 to 20)
Wallon et al26 All Seroconversion Lyons: No controls Copenhagen: screening at delivery 4 Spiramycin (3 g/day) ± pyrimethamine and sulphadiazine: 564 141 381 42 24 (20 to 27)
No treatment : 125  26  99 0 21 (14 to 29)
*

Increase in IgG and IgM titres or loss of IgM with stable or increasing IgG titre.