Table 1.
Cell Type | Pros | Cons | Latest developments | Who is working on this strategy? | Refs |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Strategy 1 - Cells as therapy | |||||
1. Skeletal myoblast |
Ischemia-resistant | Arrhythmogenesis due to lack of electromechanical coupling |
Connexin 43-expressing cell engraftment prevent post-infarct arrhythmia |
Fleischmann, B.K. bernd.fleischmann@uni-bonn.de |
[5,6] |
2. Bone marrow stem cell |
Autologous Safe |
Mixed results Paracrine effects? |
Lin−/c-Kit+ cells | Zeiher, A.M. zeiher@em.uni-frankfurt.de |
[15] |
3. Resdient cardiac stem cell |
Endogenous | Paracrine effect? Limited proliferating capacity? |
Myocardium-derived cells Epicardium-derived cells |
Marban, E. marban@jhmi.edu Gittenberge Groot, A.C. acgitten@lumc.nl |
[29] [33] |
4. Embryonic stem cell |
Highly proliferative |
Ethics Long-term benefits? Poor survival after transplantation |
Embryonic cell-derived cardiac cells |
Murry, C.E. murry@u.washington.edu Mummery, C. christin@niob.knaw.nl |
[39] |
5. Induced pluripotent stem cell |
Patient-specific | Viral infection | Reprogramming with different types of cells and factors |
Yamanaka, S. yamanaka@frontier.kyoto-u.ac.jp Hochedlinger, K. khochedlinger@helix.mgh.harvard.edu |
[49] |
Strategy 2 - Cells as target of therapy | |||||
1. GCSF | Safe | Lack of cardiomyocyte transdifferentiation from hematopoietic stem cells |
Disappointing in clinical trials |
Schomig, A. aschoemig@dhm.mhn.de |
[54] |
2. HMG (B1, A2) |
No rejection | Limited clinical data |
Activation of c-Kit+ cardiac stem cells |
Capogrossi, M.C. capogrossi@idi.it Kumuro, I. komuro-tky@umin.ac.jp |
[57] [58] |
3. Thymosin β4 |
No rejection | Limited clinical data |
Promoting coronary neovascularization |
Riley, P.R. P.Riley@ich.ucl.ac.uk |
[36] |
Strategy 3 - Cells as platform for drug screening | |||||
1. Toxicity screening |
High throughput Less expensive |
Need in vivo validation |
Expanding library of chemicals and assays |
Rubin, Lee L lee_rubin@harvard.edu |
[59] |
2. Efficacy screening |
High throughput Less expansive |
Need in vivo validation |
Use target compound to probe disease mechanism |
Zon, L.I. zon@enders.tch.harvard.edu |
[60] |
3. Disease modeling |
Patient-specific | Need in vivo validation |
Validate disease pathogenesis in patient-specific ESCs and iPSCs |
Eggan, K. eggan@mcb.harvard.edu |
[62] |