Skip to main content
. 2009 Dec;61(4):413–429. doi: 10.1124/pr.109.001461

TABLE 1.

Advantages and limitations of human and cell models

Clinical Studies Cell Models
Advantages
  • Most relevant study system

  • Pharmacokinetic as well as pharmacodynamic testing possible

  • Ability to analyze effects of interactions of multiple tissues

  • Allows investigation of environmental factors and drug-drug interactions

  • Ease of experimental manipulation

  • Controlled testing system free of in vivo confounders

  • Ability to test drugs with narrow therapeutic index

  • Genetic and expression data publicly available for hundreds of established cell lines

  • Cost-effective

  • Unlimited resource

Limitations
  • Difficult to collect large cohorts of patients for discovery and replication

  • Can be difficult to parse effects of environment from genetic effects

  • Ethical issues with studying drugs with narrow therapeutic indices

  • Not all cohorts will have detailed pharmacological data, especially retrospective cohorts

  • Phenotype may not recapitulate in vivo system

  • Subject to in vitro confounders that may affect phenotype

  • Cell lines can be generated from only a limited number of tissues

  • Cells may not express important metabolic enzymes relevant to pharmacology, such as the cytochrome P450 family

  • Establishing cell lines from tumor may alter characteristics of tumor