Table 1.
STUDY | STUDY DESIGN | TREATMENT PROTOCOL | OUTCOME | LEVEL OF EVIDENCE |
---|---|---|---|---|
Seersholm et al,1 1997 | Observational, nonrandomized study; comparison of rate of change in FEV1 in treated German patients vs untreated Danish patients | Weekly AAT therapy, 60 mg/kg | Significant difference in rate of decline in FEV1 between the groups (P = .02): treated German patients 53 mL/y vs untreated Danish patients 75 mL/y; difference of 22 mL/y | II |
AATD Registry Study Group,2 1998 | Observational, nonrandomized study | AAT therapy, 60 mg/kg (51% weekly, 25% biweekly, 22% monthly) | Significantly lower rate of FEV1 decline (mean difference 27 mL/y) in treated patients with FEV1 at 35% to 49% of predicted value (P = .03); decreased mortality in treated group (P = .02) | II |
Dirksen et al,3 1999 | Randomized controlled trial | Every 4 wk, AAT therapy (250 mg/kg) or placebo (albumin, 625 mg/kg) | Nonsignificant difference in loss of lung tissue between groups: placebo group 2.6 g/L/y vs treated group 1.5 g/L/y (P = .07) | I |
Lieberman,4 2000 | Observational, Web-based survey | AAT therapy, 60 mg/kg/wk (54% weekly, 35% biweekly, 7% monthly) | Number of lung infections decreased from 3–5/y pretreatment to 0–1/y posttreatment (P < .001) | II |
Wencker et al,5 2001 | Multicentre, retrospective cohort study; comparison of rate of FEV1 decline before and after treatment | Weekly AAT therapy, 60 mg/kg | Significant difference in rate of FEV1 decline: 49.2 mL/y pretreatment vs 34.2 mL/y posttreatment (P = .019) | II |
Dirksen et al,6 2009 | Randomized, multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-group | Weekly, AAT therapy (60 mg/kg) or placebo (2% albumin) | CT is a more sensitive outcome measure of emphysema-modifying therapy than physiology and health status; a trend toward treatment benefit from AAT augmentation therapy was demonstrated | I |
AAT—α1-antitrypsin, AATD—α1-antitrypsin deficiency, CT—computed tomography, FEV1—forced expiratory volume of air in 1 second.