Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2011 Jan 15.
Published in final edited form as: Drug Alcohol Depend. 2009 Sep 25;106(2-3):164. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2009.08.009

Table 3.

Pre-to-Post Changes During the 6-Month Active Phase Treatment: Comparison between Types of Treatment within Patient Subgroups.

Subgroup / Outcome Variable / Change Criterion Type of Treatment Test

1. IDC 2. CT 3. SE 4. GDC
Common and Fast Responders
n (%) 50 (30%) 41 (24%) 34 (20%) 44 (26%)
 ASI–Drug Use Composite Score
  d 2.34 1.86 1.89 1.80 n.s.a
  No. Reliably Improved (%) 39 (78%) 25 (61%) 22 (65%) 31 (71%) n.s.b
 Number of Days Using Cocaine During the Last 30 Days
  Reduction in the Number of Days 9.08 (7.93)*** 8.00 (7.83)*** 8.97 (7.62)*** 8.91 (7.65)*** n.s.a

Moderate Responders
n (%) 23 (21%) 34 (30%) 30 (27%) 24 (22%)
 ASI–Drug Use Composite Score
  d 1.42 1.30 1.33 0.69 n.s.a
  No. Reliably Improved (%) 13 (57%) 14 (41%) 13 (43%) 6 (25%) n.s.b
 Number of Days Using Cocaine During the Last 30 Days
  Reduction in the Number of Days 8.30 (8.63)*** 6.15 (7.24)*** 5.97 (6.59)*** 3.88 (5.75)*** n.s.a

Severe Users
n (%) 8 (19%) 10 (24%) 12 (29%) 12 (28%)
 ASI–Drug Use Composite Score
  d 0.69 1.19 0.63 1.33 n.s.a
  No. Reliably Improved (%) 2 (25%) 5 (50%) 4 (33%) 7 (58%) n.s.b
 Number of Days Using Cocaine During the Last 30 Days
  Reduction in the Number of Days 3.38 (10.18) 9.70 (8.84) *** 1.83 (7.60) 10.92 (9.39) *** n.s.a

Note: IDC = individual drug counseling, CT = cognitive therapy, SE = supportive-expressive therapy, GDC = group drug counseling, ASI = Addiction Severity Index, d = effect size (Cohen's d).

a

Analysis of variance with post-hoc comparisons.

b

χ2-Test.

c

t-test to compare pre-to-post active phase treatment change depending on type of treatment within patient subgroups.

***

p < .001.