Table 3.
Group (n=16) | Individual (n=18) | |
---|---|---|
Program costs | ||
Preparation/record keeping, h | ||
Total time, h | 57.4 | 98.8 |
Per participant time, h | 3.6 | 5.5 |
Cost per participant, $a | 78.27 | 119.73 |
Time in counseling session | ||
Total time, h | 23.2 | 190.5 |
Per participant time, h | 1.4 | 10.6 |
Cost per participant, $a | 31.67 | 230.79 |
Phone costs | ||
Cost per min per participant, $ | 0.07 | 0.03 |
Total cost, $ | 1500.78 | 571.41 |
Cost per participant, $ | 93.80 | 31.75 |
Total program costs per participant, $ | 203.73 | 382.26 |
Participant costs | ||
Time in counseling session | ||
Per participant time, h | 19.1 | 10.6 |
Cost per participant, $b | 239.22 | 132.27 |
Cost-effectiveness, program only, $c | 328.60 | 764.52 |
Cost-effectiveness, program+participant, $c | 714.43 | 1029.06 |
Data are reported as mean per provider unless noted as per participant.
Cost calculated with average provider wage of $21.81/h.
Cost calculated with average participant wage of $12.50/h.
Cost-effectiveness calculated as per participant cost divided by intent-to-treat success rate of 10% weight loss (62% in group condition and 50% in individual condition).