Table 3.
Gene groups | Branch comparisons | dN/dS | dN | dS |
---|---|---|---|---|
All 73 genes | Branch leading to Poaceae vs. all other branches | 0.0984 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. internal Poaceae | 0.0872 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | 0.0904 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.1103 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | na | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.6577 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Non-Poaceae monocots vs. other angiosperms | 0.7123 | 0.8426 | 0.6613 | |
Photosynthetic apparatus (psa-, psb-, and pet-genes) | Branch leading to Poaceae vs. all other branches | 0.0001** | 0.2746 | <0.0001** |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. internal Poaceae | 0.0001** | 0.0053* | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | 0.0001** | 0.6835 | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.0001** | 0.4589 | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | na | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.0116 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Non-Poaceae monocots vs. other angiosperms | 0.0223 | 0.2702 | 0.9622 | |
Genes expression (rpl-, rps, and rpo-genes) | Branch leading to Poaceae vs. all other branches | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | <0.0001** |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. internal Poaceae | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | na | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Non-Poaceae monocots vs. other angiosperms | <0.0001** | 0.1513 | 0.5967 | |
Photosynthetic metabolism (atp- and ndh-genes) | Branch leading to Poaceae vs. all other branches | 0.0123 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. internal Poaceae | 0.0411 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | 0.0427 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Branch leading to Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.0065 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. non-Poaceae monocots | na | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Internal Poaceae vs. other angiosperms | 0.1186 | <0.0001** | <0.0001** | |
Non-Poaceae monocots vs. other angiosperms | 0.1574 | 0.7511 | 0.8547 |
P-values were generated using Wilcoxon rank sums tests and asterisks show significant values after correction for multiple comparisons using Holm’s method, i.e., sequential Bonferroni correction (** α = 0.01, * α = 0.05). The value ‘na’ is due to model parameters in PAML analyses