Table 4.
Review of literature comparing previous studies using USG guidance for FV DC insertion
Author | Nature of Study | Sample Size (ALT/USG) | Results (ALT/USG) |
---|---|---|---|
Farrell (16) | Retrospective | 16/14 | Successful cannulation: 100%/100% |
Successful first attempt: 56.3%/85.7% | |||
Number of attempts: 1.5 ± 0.6/1.1 ± 0.4 | |||
Femoral arterial puncture: 6.3%/0% | |||
Kwon (15) | Prospective with historical controls | 38/28 | Success rate: 89.5%/100% |
Successful first attempt: 55.3%/92.9% | |||
Femoral arterial puncture: 15.8%/7.1% | |||
Hematoma: 2.6%/0% | |||
Success rate: 87%/100% | |||
Zollo (4) | Retrospective | 230/38 | Femoral arterial puncture: 11.2%/2.6% |
Hematoma: 3.9%/0% | |||
Success rate: 80%/98.2% | |||
This study | Prospective randomized controlled trial | 55/55 | Successful first attempt: 54.5%/85.5% |
Number of attempts: 1.5 ± 0.6/1.2 ± 0.4 | |||
Femoral arterial puncture: 10.9%/1.8% | |||
Hematoma: 7.2%/3.6% |