Table 2. Effect of deep brain stimulation in patients with Tourette syndrome.
Reference(s) | Patients | Stimulation site | Effect* |
Visser-Vandewalle et al., 2003 (18) | 3 | Thalamus (ventro-oral nucleus, centromedian nucleus, periventricular substance) | Observation for 8–60 months: between 72% and 90% reduction in tic frequency (video-based measurement) |
Servello et al., 2007 (12) | 18 | Thalamus (ventro-oral nucleus, centromedian nucleus) | Observation for 3–18 months: 31–95% improvement rates, as measured by YGTSS total tic score |
Maciunas et al., 2007 (13) | 5 | Thalamus (centromedian nucleus) | Blinded period with on and off phases over 4 weeks: significant (>50%) reduction in tics in 3 of 5 patients in on phase, as measured by a video score (primary target parameter) and the YGTSS (secondary target parameter), compared with off phase; improvement in only 2 of 5 patients after 3 months’ open stimulation |
Welter et al., 2008 (17) | 3 | Thalamus (centromedian nucleus and parafascicular nucleus) and globus pallidus internus | Observation for 20–60 months (10-month blinded period): 65–96% reduction in symptoms with globus pallidus internus stimulation; 30–64% reduction with thalamic stimulation (as measured by YGTSS) |
Kuhn et al., 2007 (14)Kuhn et al., 2008 (15) Kuhn et al., 2008 (16) | 8* | Nucleus accumbens (2 patients) Head of caudate nucleus (1 patient) Thalamus (4 patients) Globus pallidus internus (2 patients) | Observation for 3–60 months: improvement in symptoms as measured by YGTSS: Nucleus accumbens: 20–41% Thalamus: 33–80% Globus pallidus internus: 50% (1 patient) No response (1 patient) Caudate nucleus: 33% |
* One patient was initially treated with DBS of the globus pallidus internus, but after failure to respond new electrodes were implanted bilaterally in the thalamus;DBS, deep brain stimulation; YGTSS, Yale Global Tic Severity Scale